Barthelemy Outboxes Bey, Settles For Split Decision Win

By Jake Donovan

Rances Barthelemy took a headbutt to his temple late in round two, only to learn upon rising to his feet that the sequence was ruled a knockdown.

It was the second worst ruling made against him but didn't prevent the unbeaten Cuban from retaining his lightweight title. Barthelemy had to settle for a split decision win over Mickey Bey in a Spike-TV main event, which aired live Friday evening from Seminole Hard Rock Hotel and Casino in Hollywood, Florida.

Barthelemy won by scores of 117-110 and 116-111, overruling the ridiculous card turned in by disgraced judge Hilton Whitaker III, who somehow had Bey winning 117-110. 

Much of the buildup leading to the bout centered around the fact that Bey came in as the former title claimant although he never lost the belt in the ring. Rather, the Ohio-bred boxer was stripped of his crown last summer for failure to defend versus mandatory challenger Denis Shafikov, whom Barthelemy outpointed in their vacant title fight last December, which also aired on Spike TV. 

Bey insisted that his foe was simply keeping the belt warm for him, but fought much of the night as if he was entitled to leave with the crown without having to put in the work. Barthelemy landed the more telling blows all evening, dictated the pace and repeatedly made Bey miss. 

He did as much late in round two, with Bey overshooting considerably with a right hand that sailed past the head of the defending champ. Their heads collided, causing Barthelemy to fall to the canvas. Bey threw his arms in the air as if he just won a marathon, selling the idea of a knockdown to indecisive referee Sam Burgos, who was late on the call but picked up the count from the official timekeeper.

Barthelemy was well in control to that point, but was suddenly down on the scorecards due to the sequence resulting in a 10-8 round for Bey. He made up for lost ground in the ensuing frames, although Bey managed to land his fair share of right hands in spots. 

Apparently it was enough to sell the thought of a winning performance to judge Whitaker, infamously known for joining judge Donald Givens in awarding Paul Williams an absurd 12-round majority decision win over Erislandy Lara in what is often referred to as one of the most disgraceful scoring outcomes of the 21st Century.

The July '11 scoring scandal resulted in all three judges (including Al Bennett, who had the bout 114-114) receiving a suspension with their respective returns contingent upon completing additional training. It apparently didn't take with Whitaker, whose name is now attached to a pair of horrific scorecards going against Cuban boxers who deserved to win with room to spare. 

Nevertheless, Barthelemy has overcome far worse in life - reportedly attempting nearly 40 times to break free from his native Cuba before finally succeeding in 2007. His defection to Miami meant skipping out on a chance to fight in the 2008 Olympics, but has carved out a heck of a career for himself since turning pro in 2009. 

The undefeated lightweight titlist - who turns 30 later this month - makes his first successful defense as he improves to 25-0 (13KOs). The night marks the fifth time in his past six starts in which he has been forced to go 12 rounds, but leaves the ring with the belt. 

As a result, Bey falls to 22-2-1 (10KOs). The loss disrupts a four-fight win streak, including his disputed title win over Miguel Vazquez in their Sept. '13 clash. He never managed a single defense of the bout, but since returned with a rust-shaking win over previously unbeaten Naim Nelson last December - on the undercard of Barthelemy's win over Shafikov to claim the belt. 

Next up for Barthelemy will be a mandatory title defense versus unbeaten Richard Commey, who was seated ringside. Before then, however, he will head to the Cuban Embassy in Washington D.C. on Monday to attempt to secure a travel visa to return home to Cuba to visit the family he had to leave behind in pursuit of a better life. 

"It will feel so good to go home (to Cuba) as a world champion and be able to hug my family," Barthelemy told Spike TV's Jimmy Smith at fight's end. 


Caleb Plant preserved his unbeaten record with a 4th round knockout of Colombia's Carlos Galvan in their Spike TV-televised swing bout. 

A single left "hookercut" to the body was enough to put Galvan (12-5-1) down and out. 

Plant (13-0, 10KOs) boxed in the early rounds, feeling out aggressive (albeit ineffective) opponent while looking for the right opportunity to explode with his power shots. It appeared as if he would have to settle for his third decision win within his past four fights until creating his opening, a wicked left hand shot - half-hook, half-uppercut - found its way to Galvan's solar plexus, putting him on all fours where he remained as the referee issued the full ten count. 

The win was the second consecutive knockout for Plant, a 2012 U.S. Olympic alternate and budding middleweight prospect from Ashland City, Tenn., roughly 30 minutes from Nashville.

Emmanuel 'Manny' Rodriguez enjoyed his welcome to the bantamweight radar, soundly outpointing Alberto Guevara over 10 rounds in the Spike TV-televised co-feature attraction.

Scores were 100-90 (twice) and 99-91. 

The bout was lacking in sustained action, but still an impressive showing for Rodriguez (15-0, 10KOs). The unbeaten prospect from Vega Baja, Puerto Rico (also home to super featherweight titlist Roman 'Rocky' Martinez and this writer's beloved wife, Aida-Luz Negron) established his dominance early, but settled into a steady boxing routine once he sensed that Guevara was going to hang around for a while. 

Jake Donovan is the managing editor of Follow his shiny new Twitter account: @JakeNDaBox_v2

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by JUNIABOY on 06-04-2016

Just ban Whitaker already. No amount of re-training is going to help him.

Comment by sicko on 06-04-2016

Not worried about how Rances "Looked" vs Mickey Bey, with Bey style NOBODY can look good vs that, he took care of business and won comfortably. I like Rances Chances vs ANYBODY at 135-140, too skilled, too big and too…

Comment by PRchamp on 06-04-2016

Was at the fights last night and I don't know what it is but if I were Spike tv I wouldn't want Mayweather promotions to turn the Spike series into the dumps. Spike boxing series was great last year it…

Comment by PETUFF on 06-04-2016

Manny Rodriguez is better boxer than Leo Santa Cruz he is going to be champion no doubt!:boxing::boxing:

Comment by hhs661 on 06-04-2016

Rances didn't look great, but Bey wasn't doing much to help either. I think the headbutt that dropped him really made him change his gameplan because he finally started getting both hands up after that. Ok performance. Nothing great

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (192)
Top Headlines Juanma: I Hope Gamboa Faces Me, Doesn't Run To Fight Loma Hearn: Wilder Must Agree Now, We Won't Wait Until Fury Fight! Joshua: Povetkin Strong, But Didn't Hurt Me In The First Round Photos: Luke Campbell Avenges Loss To Yvan Mendy Dillian Whyte To Anthony Joshua: I'm Here, Ready To Fight Next Photos: Sergey Kuzmin Stops Injured David Price in Four Joshua Wants Wilder-Fury Winner April 13 at Wembley Stadium Photos: Anthony Joshua Blasts Out Povetkin - MEGA Gallery Anthony Joshua: Fans Can Decide My April Foe! Photos: Lawrence Okolie Defeats Matty Askin in a Stinker Photos: Shakhram Giyasov Breaks Down, Stops Laguna Danny Garcia: Porter Loss Was Tough, I Have A lot of Fight Left! Jayson Velez Demolishes Orlando Cruz in Two Rounds Krael Shocks Borrego on Mayweather Card, Bellows is Upset Selina Barrios Dominates Juarez: Wants Taylor, Mayer, Serrano Hearn: Fury is The Most Unentertaining Fighter I've Ever Seen! Anthony Joshua: I Got My Knockout Streak Back Povetkin Credits Joshua For Big Win, Has No Excuses Over Loss Arum Very Interested in Bringing Canelo and Golovkin To ESPN Danny Gonzalez Edges Johnny Hernandez in Tough Fight Hearn: We Want Wilder Now, It's Biggest Fight in World Boxing Firat Arslan, Emre Cukur, Tarik Sozer Victorius in Istanbul Fury Not Impressed With Joshua Win: Biggest Bum I Ever Saw Photos: Tony Bellew, Oleksandr Usyk - Face To Face at Wembley Anthony Joshua-Alexander Povetkin - CompuBox Punch Stats Joshua's Promoter: We'll Try For The Deontay Wilder Fight Again Anthony Joshua Drops, Stops Alexander Povetkin in Seventh Anthony Joshua-Alexander Povetkin: LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Jonathan Taconing Dominates Vince Paras, Retains in Manila Luke Campbell Gets Revenge, Decisions Yvan Mendy Joshua vs. Povetkin: CompuBox Historical Review Luke Campbell vs. Yvan Mendy - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Lawrence Okolie Decisions Matty Askin in Very Ugly Fight Joshua Wants To Emulate Ronaldo and Pacquiao's Longevity Lawrence Okolie vs. Matty Askin - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Anthony Joshua-Alexander Povetkin: Stats & Stakes Sergey Kuzmin Stops a Tired David Price in Four Rounds David Price vs. Sergey Kuzmin - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Shakhram Giyasov Stops Laguna in Five Rounds Promoter: Joshua Knows What He Faces In Underestimated Povetkin

Latest Active Forum Threads