How High Will Usyk Ascend in His Heavyweight Adventure?


Oleksandr Usyk will make his heavyweight debut on October 12 against someone named Tyrone Spong, a 34-year-old former kickboxer who will be an easy mark for the 2018 Fighter of the Year. The real tests will follow shortly. And I, for one, won’t be surprised if Usyk ultimately struggles.

Nothing against the Ukrainian star. He was a terrific cruiserweight, having unified all four major titles. And he obviously is gifted. The problem could be a size disadvantage against natural heavyweights.

The first person who pops into my mind when I think of Usyk is David Haye, a dominating cruiserweight who was 21-1 (with 20 knockouts) before he made the move to heavyweight full time in 2008. Usyk was 16-0 (with 12 KOs) at 200 pounds. Haye and Usyk also share two key dimensions: Both are 6 feet, 3 inches (190 cm) tall and have a 78-inch (198 cm) reach.

And Haye was no better than a pretty good heavyweight. He won a major title, the WBA version, but he did it by beating profoundly limited giant Nikolay Valuev by a majority decision. He had two successful defenses (against John Ruiz and Audley Harrison) before facing a bigger man with ability that matched his, Wladimir Klitschko.

It didn’t go well. Haye had no idea how to get inside Klitschko’s long jab and lost a wide, boring decision. He blamed the setback on a broken toe but, more likely, a good big man simply beat a good not-as-big man. Haye never again fought for a major title.

I also think of Evander Holyfield when I think of Usyk. The Hall of Famer has long been considered the greatest cruiserweight ever, having gone 18-0 (with 14 KOs) when the limit was 190 pounds and reigning as champion from 1986 until he vacated to become a heavyweight in 1988. Holyfield and Usyk also had similar dimensions, as Holyfield was 6-2½ (189 cm) and had the same reach.

Of course, Holyfield had a lot more success than Haye at heavyweight. The fiery boxer-puncher beat a long list of top big men – including Mike Tyson – en route to becoming the only fighter to win a portion of the heavyweight championship four times.

At the same time, I’ve always believed that Holyfield struggled in his three-fight series against Riddick Bowe and two meetings with Lennox Lewis in part because they were both unusually talented and naturally much bigger than he was. He had a record of 1-3-1 against those two rivals, which is eye-catching given his ability.


I think Usyk is comparable to Haye – better boxer, not as powerful – but nowhere near as good as Holyfield, who I consider one of the best fighters pound-for-pound of the past half century. The advantage Usyk has over Holyfield is that the current crop of top heavyweights is inferior to that of the last generation, which increases his chances of success. There are no Bowes or Lewises on the scene today, although Tyson Fury could’ve boxed with them.

Usyk is ranked No. 1 by the WBO, meaning he’ll be in line to face the winner of the Andy Ruiz-Anthony Joshua rematch. I think Usyk would have a difficult time against either fighter at their best, again with the size disadvantage in mind. And if he is able to get past Ruiz or Joshua, Deontay Wilder and Fury could lie ahead.

It’s difficult to predict how Usyk would do against the four top heavyweights but here are some thoughts and questions:


Ruiz isn’t as skillful as Usyk but he’s a good boxer as a result of a solid amateur career, quick for his size and much more powerful than Usyk. Is Usyk good enough to keep a strong, solid technician like Ruiz at bay for 12 rounds? And how would Usyk handle Ruiz’s solid heavyweight punching power and constant pressure from a bigger man, which can wear down a smaller fighter?


Joshua’s future is up in the air after he was dominated by Ruiz in June. If he demonstrates that he has regained his form and beats Ruiz in the rematch, he would pose a daunting challenge for Usyk. Joshua doesn’t have the skill set of Usyk but he’s much bigger than him and has the punching power to match. How would Usyk’s chin hold up against him? If Usyk can take a punch from the likes of Joshua or Wilder, he could prove to be a formidable heavyweight.


Usyk is much more skillful than Wilder but the American would tower over the Ukrainian and can end any fight with one shot. Plus, Wilder is athletic for his height. The same question we asked about Joshua goes here: What happens when Wilder lands a big punch?


Usyk would not have the same advantage over Fury that he would have against the others because Fury is an unusually good boxer. And while the Englishman isn’t a big puncher, he still has around 260 pounds behind his power shots. How can Usyk outbox a good boxer who is six inches taller than he is?

Cruiserweight-turned-heavyweight Steve Cunningham once put Fury down but he got up and scored a knockout. He also got up from Wilder’s hellish 12-round punch. Could Usyk possibly hurt him?

In the end, Usyk is a special fighter. He proved that at 200 pounds. I suspect he could beat most heavyweights, even those ranked by the sanctioning bodies. The question is how would he do against the best in the business, those who have one strength or another that might offset Usyk’s skillset?

A lot of people can’t wait to find out how he fares, which makes his move to heavyweight one of the most-intriguing stories in boxing. Who knows? Maybe he IS the second coming of Holyfield.

Michael Rosenthal was the 2018 winner of the Boxing Writers Association of America’s Nat Fleischer Award for excellence in boxing journalism. He has covered boxing in Los Angeles and beyond for almost three decades. Follow him at @mrosenthal_box.

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by GreyFox on 09-12-2019

If Usyk was that much of a sure success at heavyweight, then he'd actually be fighting a heavyweight boxer for his upcoming bout. The fact he's fighting a small kickboxer(Spong started his career as a middleweight!) tells me his team…

Comment by Jayhad23 on 09-12-2019

Ruiz the fat boy - will beat him with footwork AJ the weightlifter- Survive the first half and AJ became punching bag in the last half Wilder the street fighter - Just have to avoid the wild swings Fury the…

Comment by REDEEMER on 09-09-2019

[QUOTE=ceylon mooney;20044264]would like to see usyk with povetkin, also. but he dont match well with wilder. miuch better with joshua than wilder. much better with fury than wilder.[/QUOTE] Usyk would out maneuver Wilder easily and admits Joshua is toughest challenge…

Comment by JuniorTorres720 on 09-08-2019

Usyk is the dark horse in the heavyweight division. I like his chances because he's an exceptional boxer but just needs to get acclimated to the power and size at heavyweight. This debut fight is going to be good. Hopefully…

Comment by ceylon mooney on 09-07-2019

[QUOTE=REDEEMER;20042747]It would be a more difficult fight now , Joyce is about to pummel Miller now if Miller is serious . I think Usyk matches better with guys like Ruiz and Wilder .if favor Usyk would still get by Joyce…

Top Headlines
How Fury-Wallin Was Influenced By ESPN's Intrusion Blake Caparello: I'm Too Experienced For Joshua Buatsi! Brandun Lee Discusses Training, TV Debut on ShoBox Dirrell: 'Flint Strong' Is Us Sticking Together As A City, As A Whole Jackson Picks Canelo To Win, Believes Kovalev is Cashing Out Andre Ward Favors Errol Spence 60-40 Over Shawn Porter Anthony Crolla Vows Not To Get Emotional In Final Career Fight Peter Fury Wants Hughie Back in November, Talks Povetkin Bout Liam Walsh is Pumped For Maxi Hughes WBO Title Clash Grozny Card: Idigov, Davtaev, Salamov, Moses, More Mundine Refuses To Retire on Loss, Faces Parr on November 30 Hopkins: Pacquiao Probably Breaks My Record, Fights Into 50’s Andrew Selby: My Power is Growing, I've Never Left World Level Tyson Fury-Otto Wallin: Reasons To Be Cheerful De La Hoya: Canelo-GGG 3 in 2020 - But Canelo-Kovalev is Bigger Dmitry Kudryashov Says MMA Debut is Likely For October 12 Davison Feels Fury May Have Overtrained, Adjustments Needed Porter: Me, Spence Are No. 1 & No. 2 Welterweights World Amateur Championship Tourney in Ekaterinburg Heats Up Dirrell: Benavidez-Porter Sparring Has Nothing To Do With Me Jackson Smiles: Canelo Picked Kovalev 'Cause He's Weakest of 175 Mykal Fox Boxes Past Eudy Bernardo in One-Sided Bout Claressa Shields vs. Ivana Habazin: Non-TV Undercard Information Errol Spence vs. Shawn Porter - Undercard Additions Gervonta Davis Receives Outpour of Support at Ravens Game Carlos Takam Aims For Bigger Things After U.S. Debut Win Carlos Morales-Mercito Gesta - Golden Boy Fight Nights, 11/13 Benavidez: Cocaine Ordeal Did More Good Than Bad For Me Hearn: Fury is Very Lucky, in Any Other Country Fight is Stopped Katie Taylor, Christina Linardatou - Face To Face Regis Prograis: I Really Cannot See How Taylor Can Beat Me Daniel Dubois Has Been Voted as "Best Young Boxer" Winner Joet Gonzalez: Shakur Stevenson Not Good Enough For My Sister! Hearn on Crawford-Brook: That's For Top Rank To Pay Tyson Fury-Otto Wallin: Afterthoughts Warren: Fury Won't Be Allowed To Exercise For At Least 2 Months Blane Hyland To Debut, September 28 In Newcastle Ryan Garcia Erupts After De La Hoya Tabs Ortiz as Best Prospect De La Hoya: Everybody Wants To Sabotage Our Canelo Relationship Shannon Briggs on Ruiz-Joshua 2, Training Logan Paul
Latest Forum Threads