IF ANY OF THESE FIGHTERS RETIRED TODAY, which would make the HOF?!?!?!? (check all)

[-Antonio-]

I only picked Floyd, Pac, and Winky. Some of these votes amaze me. Jermain Taylor? If Ricky Hatton deserves to go then so does Miguel Cotto.

[Guest]

thats weird because i dont think any of them deserve to go yet.
maybe pac and winky but thats it, followed by castillo and corrales, but the guys on there like floyd and hatton with their bull**** undefeated records no way, i want to see how they do after a loss and if they can come back from defeat then sure.

You wouldn't put Rocky Marciano in the HoF?

[GEOFFHAYES]

where do you come up with this bull****?

It's common knowledge, in Britain atleast.

[!! Mr. Soprano]

where is De La Hoya, Holyfield, Barera, Jones Jr, Toney, maybe even Calzaghe on your list?

[Guest]

Hatton for being the best body puncher of his generation, best ticket seller of his generation and most exciting fighter since Nigel Benn, as well as beating the greatest 140lber ever and reigning lb4lb #1 according to many.

Maybe the British Hall of Fame that's enough, but you know as well as I do this guy was just a prospect for 40 fights and 8 years. He has one good win and ever since that win has been happy handpicking weak titleholders...

[Rudyo]

Um Mayweather dominated Castillo jackass

Pure Castillo hating at it's FINEST!

[number6]

I only voted for pbf and pac off that list based off their world level experience and achievements at different weights.
There is still time for Hatton and Wlad,but not just yet.imo

[King Koyle]

As of right now,Winky Wright,Manny Pacquiao,and Floyd Mayweather.

[Kball15]

where is De La Hoya, Holyfield, Barera, Jones Jr, Toney, maybe even Calzaghe on your list?

those are gimme's. i wanted to pick ones that would cause a discussion.

and i only had 10 spots

[DiegoFuego]

Mayweather and Pacquiao are definites if they retire right now. I think Wright and Taylor will also eventually get in. Not sure about the rest of the list.