IF ANY OF THESE FIGHTERS RETIRED TODAY, which would make the HOF?!?!?!? (check all)

[GEOFFHAYES]

Pacquaio, Mayweather, Hatton and Gatti.

And, Castillo and Corrales maybe because of their great fight last year. Yeah, actually, they would, but I can't go back and vote.

Hatton for being the best body puncher of his generation, best ticket seller of his generation and most exciting fighter since Nigel Benn, as well as beating the greatest 140lber ever and reigning lb4lb #1 according to many.

[Guest]

Winky Wright, at a push. That's it.

I should point out that I'm voting for who SHOULD get in the Hall of Fame (if they retired NOW), rather than who WOULD.

Because, as my No.1 Soul Brother K-DOGG said, by today's standards they probably all would.

[DiegoFuego]

Pacquaio, Mayweather, Hatton and Gatti.

And, Castillo and Corrales maybe because of their great fight last year. Yeah, actually, they would, but I can't go back and vote.

Hatton for being the best body puncher of his generation, best ticket seller of his generation and most exciting fighter since Nigel Benn, as well as beating the greatest 140lber ever and reigning lb4lb #1 according to many.

where do you come up with this bull****?

[blockhead]

i actually think they all deserve to go in the hall of fame

thats weird because i dont think any of them deserve to go yet.
maybe pac and winky but thats it, followed by castillo and corrales, but the guys on there like floyd and hatton with their bull**** undefeated records no way, i want to see how they do after a loss and if they can come back from defeat then sure.

[DiegoFuego]

thats weird because i dont think any of them deserve to go yet.
maybe pac and winky but thats it, followed by castillo and corrales, but the guys on there like floyd and hatton with their bull**** undefeated records no way, i want to see how they do after a loss and if they can come back from defeat then sure.

you just revealed how incredibly ****ing ****** you are. Mayweather crushed Castillo and Corrales, yet you think they have accomplished more than him? do you realize how ridiculous that is?

[blockhead]

you just revealed how incredibly ****ing ****** you are. Mayweather crushed Castillo and Corrales, yet you think they have accomplished more than him? do you realize how ridiculous that is?

well, they have proven themselves to have the character to return from defeat. in order for me to think that a fighter is hof material he has to do that or have an incredible record with incredible oposition. and other than castillo (who clearly beat floyd) and corrales, floyd hasnt done it yet.

[DiegoFuego]

well, they have proven themselves to have the character to return from defeat. in order for me to think that a fighter is hof material he has to do that or have an incredible record with incredible oposition. and other than castillo (who clearly beat floyd) and corrales, floyd hasnt done it yet.

so basically to go to the hall of fame, you have to be a loser. that's what you're saying. if you haven't lost, you can't make it. what a ****ing joke. rematches are for people that need two fights to adapt to a fighter. Floyd Mayweather doesn't need ****ing rematches because he's the best on the planet and makes his adjustment in the ring, not in a dark room watching the fight.

[Guest]

so basically to go to the hall of fame, you have to be a loser. that's what you're saying. if you haven't lost, you can't make it. what a ****ing joke. rematches are for people that need two fights to adapt to a fighter. Floyd Mayweather doesn't need ****ing rematches because he's the best on the planet and makes his adjustment in the ring, not in a dark room watching the fight.

His name is blockhead. What did you expect?

[TheHoff'sGhost]

none of them

[DiegoFuego]

His name is blockhead. What did you expect?

good point