why isnt holyfield the greatest p4p fighter ever?

[The Surgeon]

he has accomplished alot but i never really see him name up there

I rate him real high but not quite as High as a SRR Pep, Jones ect. He took it to the bigger guys in the Heavy division and did well, beating Bowe, Foreman and Lennox (I gave him the 2nd fight). Along with many others. Coming up after kickin ass at cruiser makes it even more impressive. My take on P4P is that it duznt matter what weight u are, its about skills mainly. Record and accomplishments come into it to but mainly skills IMO, also duznt hurt if uve proved ur worth in other divisions

[small_warrior]

that's a ****** question, he is a good fighter but he isn't the best p4p because there are many better fighters than him. more dominant, more skills...