It was close but Peter rightfully won.

[GunStar]

Only Toney lovers think he should have won that fight.

That's why every poll on the internet have Toney winning the fight by a huge %.

[7001]

That's why every poll on the internet have Toney winning the fight by a huge %.

He's a fan favorite.

Of course this is gonna happen. But oh well it is what it is. Peter won. We can argue until the cows come home.

[DiegoFuego]

He's a fan favorite.

Of course this is gonna happen. But oh well it is what it is. Peter won. We can argue until the cows come home.

what are you talking about? it was about 60-40 in predictions, and the Peter fans are admitting that Toney dominated. You might as well leave boxingscene at this point because no one will ever take you seriously again

[Red_Menace]

you're a complete and utter joke if you had Peter winning more than 4 rounds. Get the **** off this forum.

I had Toney winning by 3 points, with the deduction. So, I didn't see it as a landslide, by any means, but I really disagree with the way he scores his fights. You can't sit and consistently eat hard jabs and counter rights and then steal the round by landing a couple "more powerful" blows. There is something to be said for consistency through an entire round. I gave Peters rounds 3 and 5, because he rocked Toney and had him in trouble in both those rounds, but otherwise, I didn't see Peters big shots trumping Toney's. This, biggest-punch-wins scoring is ruining boxing.

[wmute]

By amateur rules, yes Toney won every single round cleanly. By pro rules, Peter won by a few rounds. There is a huge difference in the two.

"quality over quantity"???

pro rules award rounds on

clean punching
defense
ring generalship
effective aggression

not on thinking in hindsight who hurt who more,

and that is why knockdowns are scored with an entire point, following your reasoning "hurt" is double-counted.

what a great scoring systems you just invented. I usually read your posts with interest but i now realize you are willing to invent a scoring system to back up your claims

[GunStar]

He's a fan favorite.

Of course this is gonna happen. But oh well it is what it is. Peter won. We can argue until the cows come home.

He also has many haters, many people hate Toney for speaking his mind.

After seeing your scorecard I can't take anything you say about boxing seriously anymore.

[Red_Menace]

"quality over quantity"???

pro rules award rounds on

clean punching
defense
ring generalship
effective aggression

not on thinking in hindsight who hurt who more,

and that is why knockdowns are scored with an entire point, following your reasoning "hurt" is double-counted.

what a great scoring systems you just invented. I usually read your posts with interest but i now realize you are willing to invent a scoring system to back up your claims

I don't think many people really understand how boxing is supposed to be scored, but take the videogame route to scoring a fight.

[DiegoFuego]

"quality over quantity"???

pro rules award rounds on

clean punching
defense
ring generalship
effective aggression

not on thinking in hindsight who hurt who more,

and that is why knockdowns are scored with an entire point, following your reasoning "hurt" is double-counted.

what a great scoring systems you just invented. I usually read your posts with interest but i now realize you are willing to invent a scoring system to back up your claims

Kid Achilles, get the **** off the site because no one takes your bull**** opinion seriously anymore. You were so ****ing off it isn't even funny. You're easily the worst poster on this site from this day forward.

[badblood]

It was a good fight, I thought JT won the fight but there was some close rounds I guess the judges gave Peter.

[DiegoFuego]

It was a good fight, I thought JT won the fight but there was some close rounds I guess the judges gave Peter.

Toney is miles ahead of any of your bogus heavyweight favorites