It was close but Peter rightfully won.

[jswa17]

This is how I scored the fight

T P
9 10
10 9
9 10
10 9
9 10
10 9
10 10
10 9
9 9
9 10
10 9
9 10

114 - 114 A DRAW

[badblood]

he won the fight

On your card.

[BrooklynBomber]

On your card.

I wish I could see Diego's reaction after Carrales/Mayweather fight.
Diego is a good guy, really, but he is in over the top and is too emotional when it concerns his fighters.

[BrooklynBomber]

One thing though, last night really rejuvinated the NSB.

[gnostic19]

Toney out jabbed him with jabs that did little to halt his attack. Peter's jabs all, and I mean every one that landed, caused Toney to have to take a backward step or two.

How do you explain Peter's face being all red and swelled up?
Toney out jabbed Peter 3-1.

[gnostic19]

I did not here all this outrage when Valuev beat Ruiz. That was a massive robbery and every one stayed quite.

What dumbass is gonna defend Ruiz?

[Kid Achilles]

Peter's face is predisposed to swelling up and Toney's isn't. It's as simple as that. Henry Cooper's face looked like roadkill against Ali and it wasn't because Ali had a lot of punching power. Some guys just cut easier or have faces that swell more easily.

[-Antonio-]

Not a Toney nut hugger at all, just know what I saw. I can see Peter winning 5 rounds, which makes it pretty close. The 116-111 score made it a robbery though no doubt, especially with the point deduction.

[fluent2332]

Peter's face is predisposed to swelling up and Toney's isn't. It's as simple as that. Henry Cooper's face looked like roadkill against Ali and it wasn't because Ali had a lot of punching power. Some guys just cut easier or have faces that swell more easily.

yeah, that and toney was sticking his jab In his ****ing face all night

[Boxing Analyst]

I agree totally that Peter won fair and square, i watched the fight 3 times and have I no reason for Toney to win that fight. It was a close fight but Peter landed the more damage shots.