who would win cotto or castillo

[Nate Dogg]

who would win this fight miguel cotto or jose luis castillo
a really couldnt say they are two great fighters

[Nate Dogg]

i,m going with castillo

[DiegoFuego]

Castillo would win because he took flush shots from the hardest puncher in the sport for 10 rounds. Cotto's chin will not hold up in this one. He's basically a 140-147lb Corrales who doesn't carry as big a punch p4p.

[Del Coqui]

Castillo would win because he took flush shots from the hardest puncher in the sport for 10 rounds. Cotto's chin will not hold up in this one. He's basically a 140-147lb Corrales who doesn't carry as big a punch p4p.

Have you forgotten Cotto hasn't been stopped and JLC has?

[DiegoFuego]

Have you forgotten Cotto hasn't been stopped and JLC has?

but Cotto's been hurt badly at least twice and Castillo only once (against Corrales).

[Del Coqui]

but Cotto's been hurt badly at least twice and Castillo only once (against Corrales).

Don't get me wrong, I think this would be a tremendous fight, too hard to call, but Cotto has been shaken up and has found ways to survive, could you say the same for Castillo?

[maxorido]

castillo by ko.

[Boxing Analyst]

for me Cotto.

[neils7147933]

Castillo at 140.

Not sure about at welterweight. Of course, JLC would probably come into a welterweight fight at about 150... (smilie)

[Katz]

of course Castillo...