Thurman, Spence, and Hypocrisy

[MONGOOSE66]

Stick to the topic

I think he makes a good point. Why?

[Rbs3rd]

All I know is that Americans need to stop having like 3-4 guys in the 'top 10 p4p' lists where all 3-4 of the guys are in the same division and haven't faced each other. That's not how it's supposed to work.

P4p should be abolished all together.

[just the facts]

Thurman was on the p4p list until he got KTFO by a journeyman in Josesito and lost to a 40 year old pac and remained inactive for 2 years after.

How come Thurman refuses to fight a top 5 welterweight? And why is he suddenly #1 in the division?

Josesito knocked out Thurman? When?

[LeOoze]

Josesito knocked out Thurman? When?

I edited it for you. Smartass.

[JakeTheBoxer]

because ******s think Thurman is worse because he lost to Pacquiao.

[just the facts]

I edited it for you. Smartass.

Try posting factual information to make your arguments, maybe you can lose that red rep.

[DaNeutral.]

I think he makes a good point. Why?

If he makes a good point then make a new thread for that point. Why ignore the point of the thread by hiding behind a different fighter.

And if we want to compare Thurman and Spence to Crawford can Thurman and Spence both also claim to be undisputed or even champions in 3 weight divisions?

[DaNeutral.]

How come when Thurman beat Shawn Porter and Danny Garcia, everyone said Keith was a complete hype job who did not deserve to be on the p4p list?

How come when Spence beat Shawn Porter and Danny Garcia, everyone is saying Spence is top 5 p4p, some say top 3, some say 1?

Its all about pushing narratives and agendas.

[elfag]

Thurman was on the p4p list until he got KTFO by a journeyman in Josesito and lost to a 40 year old pac and remained inactive for 2 years after.

How come Thurman refuses to fight a top 5 welterweight? And why is he suddenly #1 in the division?

This, OP is talking about things Thurman did 4 and 4.5 years ago.

And yes despite what OP claims, Thurman WAS ranked highly at welter back then.

Why should he be rated so highly today

[KayDub]

How come when Thurman beat Shawn Porter and Danny Garcia, everyone said Keith was a complete hype job who did not deserve to be on the p4p list?

How come when Spence beat Shawn Porter and Danny Garcia, everyone is saying Spence is top 5 p4p, some say top 3, some say 1?

These same people are going to be okay with Spence ducking Thurman.

Don't put too much thought into it.