Grade a fighter day 12: What grade do you give Ricky Hatton?

[HitmanTommy]

A solid C-. His best win is an old Tszyu who I don't really rate that highly. He beat Paulie back when Paulie was still pretty good, so that's a plus. I thought he lost against Collazo. Castillo was way past it when he fought Hatton. I didn't like the way Hatton fought.

Thanks for the input.

[just the facts]

A solid C-. His best win is an old Tszyu who I don't really rate that highly. He beat Paulie back when Paulie was still pretty good, so that's a plus. I thought he lost against Collazo. Castillo was way past it when he fought Hatton. I didn't like the way Hatton fought.

For a fighter that only lost to Floyd and Manny, C- is pretty harsh...........

[LeOoze]

Thanks for the input.

I appreciate your threads.

[champion4ever]

Where's Arturo Gatti's poll?

[deathofaclown]

A solid C-. His best win is an old Tszyu who I don't really rate that highly. He beat Paulie back when Paulie was still pretty good, so that's a plus. I thought he lost against Collazo. Castillo was way past it when he fought Hatton. I didn't like the way Hatton fought.

Believe it or not, Castillo was rated around number 9 p4p in the ring magazine list when he and Hatton fought.

His last defeat before that was the Corrales fight, which he had avenged too.

He definitely wasn’t prime anymore, but I think it’s a better win than some give him credit for, especially stopping him in 4 rounds or whatever it was.

That body should was great too, broke a few of his ribs, I think it would’ve ended the night for almost any fighter.

[LeOoze]

For a fighter that only lost to Floyd and Manny, C- is pretty harsh...........

And tell me exactly who he beat?

[HitmanTommy]

Final roll call

[ruedboy]

Hatton was a good British fighter at 140 where his only lost was to Pac but he wasn't even average above that weight.

[pasawayako]

140 a+
147 c+

[Marchegiano]

I give him a B, agreed with the man above too