Grade a fighter day 9: What grade do you give Zab Judah?

[ruedboy]

Zab gets an A for the entertainment value of his Kostuzu KO.
But even though he was a fun guy to watch, he gets an overall B cause like others have said, the skills were there, but Zab would find a way to lose every time he stepped up in class.

[famicommander]

How’d Broner get a B?!

Because these polls are worthless. They only serve to show how ignorant the fanbase at large really is.

Broner is popular so he's a B.

Frank Bruno is well liked so he got a B, despite having only one good win in his career and being 1-5 with 5 stoppage Ls against other world champions. Shannon Briggs gets a C despite being a 2X world champion. If you put prime Briggs in there with prime Bruno, Bruno gets stopped 10 times out of 10.

[ralex]

Cory Spinks was the freaking undisputed champion of the world coming off a win over Ricardo Mayorga (who himself had just beaten Vernon Forrest twice) when Zab stopped him and you're trying to discredit that win?

Only on Boxing Scene can you knock out the undisputed champion of the world in the prime of his career and have people trash your win.

But in hindsight how good was Spinks....

[famicommander]

But in hindsight how good was Spinks....

After Zab beat him, Spinks moved up to 154 and won a world title, moved up to 160 and lost to the undefeated and lineal champion Jermain Taylor by split decision, then moved back down to 154 and won another world title.

So yeah, Spinks was great and he was at his very peak when Zab stopped him.

Again, this should go without saying, but Spinks was the undisputed and lineal welterweight champion of the world coming off a great win and Zab stopped him. There is no way you can possibly discredit a win over a guy who earned ALL the belts and the lineal title in the ring.

[djtmal]

Solid B......

[Rockybigblower]

A for speed.
F for hat.
C+ Overall.

Come on man....F for the mans hat. Hes more stylish than that.

[2Shotz]

remember when he crashed through a shower door before his fight w mosley?

[Ca$ual Fan]

Zab Judah is a perfect example of an eye test gone wrong. Looks like he’s got the package but when thoroughly tested, fails miserably.

He’s not as actually good as what he displays

[alexguiness]

Regarding Broners B.

A broken clock is right twice a day.

[daggum]

His career is definitely better than most and could had been a first ballot if his won the right fights he could had easily won. C+ for his career. But his skills in his best night is a A- .

Idk how broner got a B.

i know right thats such garbage. broner is an A+ fighter. robbed. stop the steal folks