Better resume: Oscar de La Hoya or Felix Trinidad?

[sugar ray lenrd]

[QUOTE=The Big Dunn;
But that doesn’t erase rounds 1-8.

Brother Oscar didn’t win every round from 1-8.

The judges got it right. Even you acknowledged that he ran during those late rounds. There are consequences for running. I rest my case.
Tito won! Just like Floyd got the win against Castillo & Maidana 1. It’s in the record books.
And I will not respond to any more about this! At this point it’s pointless.

[LeOoze]

bump....

[Regge]

Oscar's top wins

Paez
RUELAS
Chavez 2x
Whitaker
Camacho
Quartey
Vargas
Mayorga

And most felt he beat Tito and Mosley in the rematch and his fight with Floyd was super close.

Tito

Blocker
campus
Camacho
Whitaker
DLH
Reid
Vargas
Joppy

I think Oscar has a close but clear better resume but I was a huge fan of Tito one of my all time favs.

[Idunnoshet]

Oscar Dela Hoya was the better boxer and has the better resume.

[Malvado]

Oscar's top wins

Paez
RUELAS
Chavez 2x
Whitaker
Camacho
Quartey
Vargas
Mayorga

And most felt he beat Tito and Mosley in the rematch and his fight with Floyd was super close.

Tito

Blocker
campus
Camacho
Whitaker
DLH
Reid
Vargas
Joppy

I think Oscar has a close but clear better resume but I was a huge fan of Tito one of my all time favs.

Think Genaro Hernandez (32-0-1, 15 KOs) or Miguel Angel Gonzalez (41-0, 31 KOs) should be considered over Paez who was a natural featherweight. Both Hernandez and Gonzalez were undefeated champions and renown big punchers at 130-140.

Comparable to the win against IBF Lightweight champ Rafael Ruelas (43-1, 33 KOs).

Genaro and Rafael were tall for their divisions, both standing at 5'11.

There is also Arturo Gatti (33-4, 27 KOs) before his trilogy with Micky Ward.

[BoxingParadigm]

Oscar's resume seems better to me, but Trinidad's peak was really good. I wish they would've rematched at 154lbs.

[djtmal]

It's tight but I give it to De La

[CubanGuyNYC]

It’s great that these two fought in the same era and actually fought each other while still in their primes. That seems to be going the way of the dodo. Close comparison with these men, but the nod goes to Oscar. And head-to-head, DLH threw away a clear win by literally running. Even so, I still think he did enough to get the victory over Tito.

[-Kev-]

Oscar De La Hoya by far. DLH also beat him in their fight.

I remember when that fight was being promoted, I was rooting for Trinidad. At the time, I was a kid and I just liked Trinidad more. I laughed at DLH getting robbed, it was just funny to me. But yeah, he did get robbed. I wasn’t a DLH fan yet but he won that fight.

[-Kev-]

You got t wrong, Whitaker avoided Tito. Quartey & Mosley? You gotta be Kidding! Tito would’ve dismantle any of them! Where are you getting that from?

Shane Mosley would’ve boxed circles around Trinidad. It’s a shame that fight didn’t happen. Mosley’s hand speed would’ve been too much for Trinidad.