Originally posted by bluebeam
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Is there any date set for Gennady Golovkin next fight?
Collapse
-
Originally posted by Boxing-1013 View PostHuh? I said 1 judge had the fight over after 8 rounds. All 3 judges had it over after 9 rounds. What's not to get? lol
As I said before, people can think whatever they want about GGG. I think at minimum he was a consummate pro who destroyed good pros and never had an off night against them. That by itself is impressive and puts him up there with other greats all-time at 160. Just how it is man. Look at resumes/records if one really wants to. Most guys are about 50-50 vs other greats. Most pros dominate vs other good pros (and even have a few losses/controversies). I think GGG was a little better than that on both fronts but that's just how I saw it.
And the only 'boxing groupie' here would be the guy(s) who insist Canelo actually won either of those fights lol. Everyone with any sense knows the deal - Canelo is the cash king in boxing and he paid GGG for his belts and zeroes (draw and loss). It is what it is. GGG got paid, Canelo got an official draw and win when he deserved 2 Ls. Everyone knows that except the real groupies dawg.
Very hard to compare eras even when they are somewhat close by in years. I think you could make a case that RJJ, Felix, Oscar and Taylor twice are better fights than Canelo twice, Jacobs, Derevy and Brook/Murray. But I think most people would say they are very similar level fights.
I would also say that Bhop's win over Glen Johnson would be on his list of accomplishments over a few of those fights you cited. Glen was undefeated at that time and that was a great win at that time. Tito and Oscar were not MWs and their records around those fights proved that. They were about 50-50 in their fights around the Bhop fight around that weight.
I think you also have to factor in what you saw in those fights. And I saw GGG perform better in those fights than Bhop did. Bhop has 3 Ls whereas the only really close fight for GGG for me in those 5 is vs Derevy. GGG KOed basically all the 'other' guys, Bhop was about 50/50 with decisions and KOs, with some uninspiring performances. Fair to factor in Bhop's age vs Taylor as well though.
I think GGG faced more solid comp in the other fights between the two at MW. Besides JDJ, Bhop's is a list of 'who'. It's basically littered with mandatory 'Dominic Wade' types. GGG for me at least has mostly solid pros on his list who were somewhat of a challenge. He just made them look like less of one because he was that dominant at the time (and they weren't top level).
If anyone looked at when GGG was active all the guys who would have been "signature wins" and near every one of them refused to fight GGG.
Even Canelo camped out at 155 for years only to win the WBC 160 strap to drop it and hold out for longer.
Ask them to give you a list GGG avoided the absolute best they can do is come up with two names.
Lara, who is a career 154 guy and Ward, who declined the fight in 2013 only to "offer" a fight in 2015.
Neither guy was in the same division as GGG and they also can't give you a time table of when these fights could have happened.
At least GGG did the best he could and im pretty sure every guy in between his titles were ranked top 10 at the time at 160.
The only exception is Brook and GGG didnt even ask for that fight. He was signed to fight Eubank Jr only to have him back out.
But all the Canelo groupies applaud Canelo for hand picking Khan and moving him up two divisions and knocking him out easy lmfaooooooooo
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by R-Hand Southpaw View PostThe guys saying GGG is overhyped or overrated or just a bum can only state it as an opinion and cant support it with facts.
If anyone looked at when GGG was active all the guys who would have been "signature wins" and near every one of them refused to fight GGG.
Even Canelo camped out at 155 for years only to win the WBC 160 strap to drop it and hold out for longer.
Ask them to give you a list GGG avoided the absolute best they can do is come up with two names.
Lara, who is a career 154 guy and Ward, who declined the fight in 2013 only to "offer" a fight in 2015.
Neither guy was in the same division as GGG and they also can't give you a time table of when these fights could have happened.
At least GGG did the best he could and im pretty sure every guy in between his titles were ranked top 10 at the time at 160.
The only exception is Brook and GGG didnt even ask for that fight. He was signed to fight Eubank Jr only to have him back out.
But all the Canelo groupies applaud Canelo for hand picking Khan and moving him up two divisions and knocking him out easy lmfaooooooooo
Comment
-
Originally posted by Boxing-1013 View PostHey man you get it. GGG wasn't a perfect fighter but he was really really good and didn't really have many holes in his game. Just a great fighter in any era
Comment
-
Originally posted by bluebeam View PostMacklin, murray, adama, wade, monroe, rubio, lemiuex, rosado, proska, geale, rolls.
None of them have a signature win. So how can i rank them as good wins for gennady when they have no notable wins before or after the ggg fight?
And i defeinitely had canelo winning the rematch. Canelo came foward the whole fight amd golovkin was no monster. I had ggg winning the first fight tho
Ishida for example - solid pro, KOed Kirkland. Went 24 rounds just prior to GGG fight, with Paul Williams and Pirog. Then he fights GGG and gets taken out in 3 rounds, his only KO defeat of his career. There are just a lot of instances like that for GGG where he really dominated against guys like that who were solid, and proved that they were solid against other guys.
To run through all of them with no issues at all is impressive to me. When I've studied other fighters who have similar matchups, they usually 'struggle' or lose in a couple of those types of fights out of 10.
To put it another way, BHop had 7 fights at 160 vs Robert Allen (3), Antwun Echols (2) and Mercado (2). Adding in a few more guys like that, like half of BHop's run at 160 were Rolls and Wade types. Amateur type guys who weren't really solid pros. I think GGG had just a couple of fights like that (Rolls and Wade) in his run.
Idk man I thought Canelo fought well in both fights really. Was impressed with him in different ways in both fights. But to me he had the same problem in both. Fought well in spurts, and had some good shots landed. But he was outworked basically every round, which gave GGG some clear rounds and made for some close rounds where Canelo landed the best shot or combo of the round.
I've watched those fights a number of times and I honestly can't recall coming away from any round saying 'OK clear Canelo round'. GGG has just been a tough matchup for him because GGG is so active and always scoring and Canelo has always fought in spurts.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Al Broker View PostHe doesn’t get anything other than being a Mary Cone. Willing to be he’s Fap Fap Boom’s alt. Just crying over criticisms over GGG. Even GGG’s wife yells “Mary Cone, dinner’s ready!” She even yells in Spanish and the neighbors laugh!
Comment
-
Originally posted by TonyGe View PostHe might beat some of them but at Middleweight he wasn't all that. Trinidad was a very good fighter but Middleweight wasn't his division.
sure but based on Tito winning the same amount of MW titles in the ring as GGG at the same stage of their career, hes not anything at MW.
so MW wasnt GGG's division either....it was even less GGG's division!Last edited by DreamFighter; 09-06-2020, 07:43 AM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by DreamFighter View PostJoppy win tops GGG's entire career set of wins.
sure but based on Tito winning the same amount of MW titles in the ring as GGG at the same stage of their career, hes not anything at MW.
so MW wasnt GGG's division either....it was even less GGG's division!
Comment
Comment