Was Castillo robbed of a victory over Floyd Mayweather Jr.?

[Super_Lightweight]

The punch stats are not a 'weak' argument whatsoever. They describe exactly what the majority of boxing fans saw when they watched that fight.

[DiegoFuego]

I've scored it a draw at 113-113 and a Mayweather win at 114-112, but never a Castillo victory. Those punchstats are bull**** and anybody who watches the fight knows that. Show me 3 rounds where Castillo landed more than just arm punches.

[Hitman18]

Now if anybody watched the three rounds posted at you tube, Harold Lederman had Castillo up by three points after the 11th, even Larry Merchant, who always scores it wrong, had Castillo up by a point, and in my eyes, Castillo won the last round. Floyd kept rabbit punching or hitting Castillo's ears. He kept holding on to Castillo's arm cuz he knew he was going to get hit hard and didn't want it to happen. At the bell of the last round, Floyd hit Castillo with like four or five punches, just at or even after the bell. He's a punk and Castillo was robbed.

[DiegoFuego]

The punch stats are not a 'weak' argument whatsoever. They describe exactly what the majority of boxing fans saw when they watched that fight.

yeah but you hate Mayweather for being greater than Roy so your opinion means jack**** when it comes to discussing one of the greatest fighters of all time, Floyd Mayweather Jr.

[{BrownBomber}]

The fight was close but n oway the fight could go either way,Castillo CLEARLY won a close 1.
The second fight was close also and rightfully scored.
Still doesnt make justice, the second fight oddly enough was scored
closer than the first. So what does that tell you?

[deliveryman]

I just digged up my scorecard on the fight. (I save my scorecards on my comp)

Round  Mayweather  Castillo
1         10          9 
2         10          9
3         9          10 
4         10          9 
5         10          9
6         9          10
7         9          10
8         9           9   (Castillo won the round - but a point deducted)
9        10           9
10        9           9   (Floyd point deduction) 
11       10           9 
12        9          10
Total    [B]114         112[/B]

[realboxingfan]

yeah but you hate Mayweather for being greater than Roy so your opinion means jack**** when it comes to discussing one of the greatest fighters of all time, Floyd Mayweather Jr.

LOL......you are delusional. you probably have prettyboy Floyd pajamas

[DiegoFuego]

The fight was close but n oway the fight could go either way,Castillo CLEARLY won a close 1.
The second fight was close also and rightfully scored.
Still doesnt make justice, the second fight oddly enough was scored
closer than the first. So what does that tell you?

The judges didn't want to catch the same heat the judges in the first fight caught? 6 judges have said Mayweather is better than Castillo now, so I think the Castillo (Mexican) fans and Mayweather haters need to let it go. This happened four years ago.

[realboxingfan]

I just digged up my scorecard on the fight. (I save my scorecards on my comp)

Round  Mayweather  Castillo
1         10          9 
2         10          9
3         9          10 
4         10          9 
5         10          9
6         9          10
7         9          10
8         9           9   (Castillo won the round - but a point deducted)
9        10           9
10        9           9   (Floyd point deduction) 
11       10           9 
12        9          10
Total    [B]114         113[/B]

your score card is doo doo

[DiegoFuego]

I just digged up my scorecard on the fight. (I save my scorecards on my comp)

Round  Mayweather  Castillo
1         10          9 
2         10          9
3         9          10 
4         10          9 
5         10          9
6         9          10
7         9          10
8         9           9   (Castillo won the round - but a point deducted)
9        10           9
10        9           9   (Floyd point deduction) 
11       10           9 
12        9          10
Total    [B]114         113[/B]

that's such an awesome idea. you're my favorite poster for the day, congratulations and thanks for the inspiration.