Was Castillo robbed of a victory over Floyd Mayweather Jr.?

[amagnin]

you like pitty patter pillow hand type fighters thats why

Good answer with a lot of solid facts in there.

[DiegoFuego]

Don't people on both sides think that the arguments on both sides prove that while this may not have been the decision you wanted/came up with it was not a robbery. Some had Castillo winning close, some had Mayweather winning close, some had it a draw. IMO, this kind of split indicates the fight was highly competitive but not a robbery.

It's a lot like Taylor vs. Wright, which ended up being a draw. Only difference is at the time of Mayweather-Castillo I, all the fans had Castillo winning and all the experts aside from HBO had Mayweather winning. Now that Mayweather is on top of boxing, a lot more people hate him and will vote against him on this fight.

[DiegoFuego]

you like pitty patter pillow hand type fighters thats why

and you like come forward, no defense, "you hit me, I miss you" type fighters

[DiegoFuego]

What's even more embarrassing for a lot of these Castillo fans is Mayweather had one good hand and still won a close fight. He dominated Castillo in the rematch.

[Hitman18]

Listen. Did you just start to watch boxing yesterday?

a) it's not always about who lands more.
b) harold lederman is not god.

Its not always about who lands more!!! So you're saying that its sometimes about who lands less right???
Harold Lederman isn't god, but a good opinion, and person who along with thousands of others saw Castillo win the fight. IMO you just started watching boxing yesterday.

[realboxingfan]

and you like come forward, no defense, "you hit me, I miss you" type fighters

yes i do."fighters" not spit thier mouth piece out when they get hurt 6ft tall weighing 135lb cheaters.chump.

[amagnin]

It's just all the people on Mayweather's **** that are saying he won, including the paid judges. The whole audience at the fight, the boxing analysists, boxing experts on the internet and in the magazines, and well enough anybody who watched the fight (whether or not Castillo fans) saw that Castillo was robbed. The punchstats say that Castillo was robbed.

The audience at a fight is by no means an accurate way of judging. The fans always get behind whoever came on late in the fight which we have already established was Castillo. And the rest of your post is just untrue. Reporters at ringside were split as were internet writers and magazines. The punchstats again don't accurately represent the professional boxing scoring system that scores each round rather than the whole fight. Listen if you think Castillo won that is totally fine, but why don't you respsect other people's opinions as well. And the judges being paid... for what?

[deliveryman]

Its not always about who lands more!!! So you're saying that its sometimes about who lands less right???
Harold Lederman isn't god, but a good opinion, and person who along with thousands of others saw Castillo win the fight. IMO you just started watching boxing yesterday.

Huh?

It's also about who lands

a) the harder shots
b) the cleaner shots
c) the more effective shots

[Hitman18]

Everybody, read this.

http://www.********boxing.com/CastillovsMayweather.html

[amagnin]

you like pitty patter pillow hand type fighters thats why

You know what's funny. Floyd has a higher KO% than your boyfriend Antonio Margarito. So who are you calling pillow hand?