Has the word "robbery" lost all meaning?

[Shadoww702]

By your OWN definition, Pac/Bradley 1 was not a robbery.

Whitaker/Chavez was about keeping someone alive.

Williams/Lara - yes, that was a robbery.

Pac/Marquez 3 - arguably a robbery.

Wilder/Fury 1 - arguably a robbery.

Eubank/Schommer - robbery, admitted by Eubank himself.

Hopkins/Calslappy - arguably a robbery.

Foreman/Briggs - not a robbery, close.

Leonard/Hagler - not a robbery, close.

Mayweather/Castillo - not a robbery, close.

Mayweather/Maidana - not a robbery, close.

Pac/Horn - not a robbery, close.

Pac/Thurman - not a robbery, close.

Thurman/Porter - not a robbery, close.

Spence/Porter - not a robbery, close.

PAC/Bradley 1 I always said was close.

Williams/Lara Robbery

No JMM/Pc was a Robbery

Wilder/Fury 1 close (2) 10-8 rounds is 4. So what’s 1-2 more???

Which Castillo fight?

[Combat Talk Radio]

No JMM/Pc was a Robbery

That third fight was straight suspect. I'm sorry.

Wilder/Fury 1 close (2) 10-8 rounds is 4. So what’s 1-2 more???

I gave Wilder 2 rounds - the 2 he got knockdowns. Nothing else.

Which Castillo fight?

They both were close and neither was a robbery.

[ruedboy]

7-5 or 5-7 is a robbery if it puts an L on a fighter’s record who didn’t deserve it.

True. A robbery is taking a win that you didn't earn, doesn't matter if it's by 1 round or 10.

[_Maxi]

They are robberies when at least one judge is clearly bought. IE: GGG-Canelo I one judge had Canelo winning 10 rounds.

[aboutfkntime]

Funny enough, I have never seen either one of you post a scorecard from a fight...just odd.

Btw...all scoring criteria matter in boxing...defense etc are important.

But the only thing you ACTIVELY score is the punches that land and their effectiveness...that people on a boxing forum don't understand this is really sad.

But it is what it is! You guys are good fans and the sport needs fans too!!

what do you think we are... excitable little fanboys, like you

I haven't scored a fight for YEARS... probably decades

funnily, the casual-fan moron that I was referring to... is you

you embarrassed yourself when you made the post below...

------------------------------

proves that he has no idea how to score a professional boxing match...

I'll also tell you how I score them...generally give a 'full point' for a good hard clean shot...and a 'half point' for a punch that is a scoring blow but isn't necessarily super hard or clean.
https://www.boxingscene.com/forums/s...3#post20372893

------------------------------

punches that are neither hard, nor clean... are NOT official scoring criteria, you muppet

you literally have no idea how to score a professional boxing match

effective aggression... defence... and ring generalship... ARE official scoring criteria... and do factor into the judges scoring... no matter how badly you need that not to be the case

what a fkn idiot

#embarrassing

[Shadoww702]

what do you think we are... excitable little fanboys, like you

I haven't scored a fight for YEARS... probably decades

funnily, the casual-fan moron that I was referring to... is you

you embarrassed yourself when you made the post below...

------------------------------

proves that he has no idea how to score a professional boxing match...



------------------------------

punches that are neither hard, nor clean... are NOT official scoring criteria, you muppet

you literally have no idea how to score a professional boxing match

effective aggression... defence... and ring generalship... ARE official scoring criteria... and do factor into the judges scoring... no matter how badly you need that not to be the case

what a fkn idiot

#embarrassing

He does a lot of this for his favorite boxers....



And this




I still want him to collect his GGG money and get KTFO! He shows up and DEMANDS his $$$$$ saying GGG won doe! I'll count to 2 before he gets punched on-site

His crayon scorecard is his prove GGG won....

[Shadoww702]

That third fight was straight suspect. I'm sorry.



I gave Wilder 2 rounds - the 2 he got knockdowns. Nothing else.



They both were close and neither was a robbery.

8-4 is that really a robbery for wilder??? You saw no other round close not even round 1???

[Shadoww702]

To me it is a 'robbery' when I can't see the result that happened...Ward-Kov 1, Hooker-Perez that same night, etc.

I guess reasonable people can differ however as to what constitutes a robbery...for one, I can't say Fury-Wilder 1 was a robbery..it was reasonable to get Wilder 5 rounds imho.

A big problem that adds to the uproar though is when judges come out with cards way out of line, even if it is reasonable that the fighter won...almost always those cards are in favor of the A-side fighter...so it just adds fuel to the fire that there was a 'robbery'...basically another way of saying 'this guy never had a chance'.

Is that 4 your 8-4 card on GGG/Canelo 2????

[Boxing_1013]

what do you think we are... excitable little fanboys, like you

I haven't scored a fight for YEARS... probably decades

funnily, the casual-fan moron that I was referring to... is you

you embarrassed yourself when you made the post below...

------------------------------

proves that he has no idea how to score a professional boxing match...



------------------------------

punches that are neither hard, nor clean... are NOT official scoring criteria, you muppet

you literally have no idea how to score a professional boxing match

effective aggression... defence... and ring generalship... ARE official scoring criteria... and do factor into the judges scoring... no matter how badly you need that not to be the case

what a fkn idiot

#embarrassing

Bro how you can have such a big opinion on fights/who won/lost and you don't even score fights? lol like wtf man.

I honestly can't believe you just said that but then again I'm not really surprised.

[Boxing_1013]

Is that 4 your 8-4 card on GGG/Canelo 2????

Didn't you have it 7-5 to GGG in fight 1? And why are you following me around about that fight lol...I didn't even bring up GGG-Canelo in this thread little homie.