James Toney (1991) vs Canelo Alvarez (2019) at middelweight who wins and why

[Curtis Harper]

Toney would need to land a Nunn type shot. Otherwise, Nelo out works him.

[kidbazooka]

Canelo hits harder is more accurate has a better chin and is much more disciplined than Tony.

Canelo by UD.

[NORMNEALON]

I would pick toney via UD . He would outwork canelo down the last stretch his stamina is way better and punches better in combination, also toney would counter him.all night up until that point . Canelo would have to try and pot shot and work the body on the inside. I doubt canelo could win this fight but damn he would make it good .

[satiev1]

No way in hell tony wins a decision against canelo.

[TheUptownKid]

Canelo has struggled versus good defenders and toney was one of the best. Toney also could make you look really bad and I think he is the physically stronger of the two which would play a role

[TheUptownKid]

Canelo hits harder is more accurate has a better chin and is much more disciplined than Tony.

Canelo by UD.

What? Have you watched James Toney? True Toney got fat when he got older but at middleweight he was a savage.

[QueensburyRules]

Canelo has struggled versus good defenders and toney was one of the best. Toney also could make you look really bad and I think he is the physically stronger of the two which would play a role

- -Take the challenge that all fail at!

Whose the best prime fighter where he showed good defense?

Stay tuned, boys, this gonna get good!

[Lomasexual]

Toney, clearly and easily.

Canelo lost to GGG. Toney would have clowned GGG. Toney had some legit, ATG abilities. His inside fighting was insanely good.

How is this even a question?