Shields vs Ali

[Carpe Diem]

Who do you have winning prime for prime?

[buddyr]

Shields. Ali was not that good. She damn near lost to Fraizer's daughter(and probably did depending on how you scored the fight) who had just STARTED boxing after seeing Laila on tv and wanted a quick check by bringing in their dad's rivalry. She was a joke and I've been telling people this since she was boxing. Padded record of bums and avoided any real competition.

[THC]

Shields comfortably beats Ali.

Wolfe dominates Shields.

[NORMNEALON]

Shields comfortably beats Ali.

Wolfe dominates Shields.

Agreed especially at this point. Shields would be a massive favorite .

[Madison Boxing]

Ali stops shields

[famicommander]

Shields probably out points Ali.

Christy Martin, Lucia Rijker, Ann Wolfe, Anne Sophie Mathis? Any one of those ladies starches Claressa.

[Robbie Barrett]

Ali would walk straight through Shields.

[joseph5620]

Shields probably out points Ali.

Christy Martin, Lucia Rijker, Ann Wolfe, Anne Sophie Mathis? Any one of those ladies starches Claressa.

Martin and Rijker were way too small to fight Shields.

[joseph5620]

Who do you have winning prime for prime?

It would be a good fight. People with revisionist history crap on Laila Ali and say she didn't fight anybody.

She twice easily stopped Valerie Mahfood. A fighter that stopped Ann Wolfe. In fact Wolfe couldn't stop her in the rematch and had a hard time with her. So......

[famicommander]

Martin and Rijker were way too small to fight Shields.

Martin won a WBC belt at 154, won fights at 160, and fought at 168.

Rijker was indeed probably too small.