Comments Thread For: Arum: Pacquiao is FOTD - NOT Mayweather - It's Not Even Close!

[hugh grant]

The loss the Jeff Horn was really bad though...

But it was a robbery and in Australia, no need to mention it really. Floyd making Maidana look so elite wasn't great and was bad in many peoples eyes also. Floyd only fighting 5 years is real bad and no coming back from that

Floyd isn't FOTD but his fans argue he has the single best wins? That's subjective. Countless people would conclude Pac has the single best win over Thurman.

[BoomBapTrap]

Now, had Manny done what he should have, and rematched that dominant loss, he would be a two-belt holder and in much stronger contention. Still not above Floyd because Floyd had his hand raised over BOTH Manny and Carnelo.

The man beat TWO Fighter of the Decade contenders with EASE.

He struggled with PAC.
Could’ve gone either way, or even draw.

“You fighting like you’re scared boy!”

[UNBANNED]

Floydie retired barely halfway thru the decade. Meanwhile, Manny still fighting elites regularly, and winning.

So KTFO6, a gift in JMM3, losing to a plumber in Australia, and losing 10-2 to Floyd win you FOTD??

This really is the WWE now XD XD XD

[ThatDude44]

Manny is fighter of the decade= opinion.
Floyd school Manny when they fought= fact.
Can't argue facts

[UNBANNED]

But it was a robbery and in Australia, no need to mention it really. Floyd making Maidana look so elite wasn't great and was bad in many peoples eyes also. Floyd only fighting 5 years is real bad and no coming back from that

Pacquia lost cleanly to Horn:

"Based on the analysis, the WBO said Pacquiao won the third, eighth and ninth rounds by 100 percent, the fifth round by 80 percent and the 11th by 60 percent. Horn was given the first, sixth and 12th rounds by 100 percent, the second, fourth and seventh by 80 percent and the 10th by 60 percent.

"From the results, it can be established that Pacquiao won 5 rounds while Horn won 7 rounds," the WBO statement said"

https://www.espn.com/boxing/story/_/id/19957397/five-independent-judges-confirm-decision-jeff-horn-manny-pacquiao

Pac made JMM look elite 4 times...and Pac lost to Joe Horn. Floyd having a rough night against Maidana (but still winning clearly) is not the same.

Floyd isn't FOTD but his fans argue he has the single best wins? That's subjective. Countless people would conclude Pac has the single best win over Thurman.

Canelo and Crawford are my FOTD picks. Crawford was lineal and unified at 140 and has dominated every fight at 135 and 147. The problem for TC is he hasn't had major opponents willing to fight him....tough when you're the best.

Canelo has a great body of work though and that KO of Kovalev - no matter how fixed it looked - was icing on the cake

[hugh grant]

Pacquia lost cleanly to Horn:

"Based on the analysis, the WBO said Pacquiao won the third, eighth and ninth rounds by 100 percent, the fifth round by 80 percent and the 11th by 60 percent. Horn was given the first, sixth and 12th rounds by 100 percent, the second, fourth and seventh by 80 percent and the 10th by 60 percent.

"From the results, it can be established that Pacquiao won 5 rounds while Horn won 7 rounds," the WBO statement said"

https://www.espn.com/boxing/story/_/id/19957397/five-independent-judges-confirm-decision-jeff-horn-manny-pacquiao

Pac made JMM look elite 4 times...and Pac lost to Joe Horn.

Floyds never fought outside country, so cant really hold loss against horn against Pac! Pac has 3 wins over JMM if not scorecard error which is better than cheated scales win.

Canelo has a great body of work though and that KO of Kovalev - no matter how fixed it looked - was icing on the cake

Yes, id agree Nelo has done more than floyd since his loss to Floyd. More than made up his loss to floyid.

[BoomBapTrap]

Pacquia lost cleanly to Horn:

"Based on the analysis, the WBO said Pacquiao won the third, eighth and ninth rounds by 100 percent, the fifth round by 80 percent and the 11th by 60 percent. Horn was given the first, sixth and 12th rounds by 100 percent, the second, fourth and seventh by 80 percent and the 10th by 60 percent.

"From the results, it can be established that Pacquiao won 5 rounds while Horn won 7 rounds," the WBO statement said"

https://www.espn.com/boxing/story/_/id/19957397/five-independent-judges-confirm-decision-jeff-horn-manny-pacquiao

Pac made JMM look elite 4 times...and Pac lost to Joe Horn. Floyd having a rough night against Maidana (but still winning clearly) is not the same.



Canelo and Crawford are my FOTD picks. Crawford was lineal and unified at 140 and has dominated every fight at 135 and 147. The problem for TC is he hasn't had major opponents willing to fight him....tough when you're the best.

Canelo has a great body of work though and that KO of Kovalev - no matter how fixed it looked - was icing on the cake

No, no he didn’t.

NSB and there false agendas.

[UNBANNED]

Floyds never fought outside country, so cant really hold loss against horn against Pac! Pac has 3 wins over JMM if not scorecard error which is better than cheated scales win.



Yes, id agree Nelo has done more than floyd since his loss to Floyd. More than made up his loss to floyid.

Canelo and Crawford and Loma had best decades. Manny in the discussion too, but not the best decade...losing the clearest way possible in nasty rivalry with JMM, losing to Horn, and losing to Floyd. Mannys decade is more impressive bc of his age, but it still doesnt Top Canelo or Loma or TC in my HUMBLE opinion

[UNBANNED]

No, no he didn’t.

NSB and there false agendas.

I used a source. So the 3 professinal judges that scored the fight as well as 3/5 independent professional judges scored Horn the winner.

Theres no NSB agenda...you are the agenda. I used sources not sourpuss opinions.

[Vodkaholic]

Obviously. No reasonable person could choose someone else as fotd