Should Claressa Shields be on any respectable P4P list?

[W1LL]

One of the most decorated female Amateurs of all-time.

9-0 as a Pro, won World titles in her 4th fight. Unified Super Middleweight champion, Unified/Undisputed/Lineal Middleweight champion, beat one of the longest-reigning champions in Female boxing history. Fighting for titles in a third weight division in January. Talk of fighting undisputed Welterweight Cecilia Braekhus in a fourth weight class next year.

I personally feel like she deserves a spot on any P4P list.

[famicommander]

She's not even women's Pound for Pound Queen. That'd be Braekhus, who has the Ring P4P belt to back it up.

[KING MEAT]

take this sh\t to the latino lounge.
****** talk is over there.

[4truth]

P4P list: you're doing it wrong.

[Larry the boss]

do they have a womans p4p list?

[famicommander]

do they have a womans p4p list?

Braekhus was awarded the first ever Ring Pound for Pound women's belt last year.

[boliodogs]

If it is a special for women only pfp list then yes. If you want to rank her in the top 10 with guys like Canelo, Inoue, Crawford, Loma, Spence, GGG etc I say absolutely not. Any pro male middleweight boxer in the top 500 would slaughter her. I believe in women's rights but they don't have the right to be rated better than they are, Women are not allowed to box men in open competition because the fights would be too one sided in favor of the men. The strongest men are always stronger than the strongest women and this can be proven in any athletic avent that can be timed or measured. It could be a mile race, a 100 yard dash, a swimming race, throwing a discus or shot, high jump, long jump, pole vault or anything else and the best men always beat the best women. Women do notcompete with men in tennis or basketball or soccer because they just are not good enough. Boxing is no different. So I say no pfp ranking for her unless it's against women and only women. She has no business being ranked better than the best male boxers pfp because she is not good enough and no women is.

[The D3vil]

Well, I'd have her 2nd P4P after Breakhus on mine for women.

[Ivansmamma]

Its a pound for pound list not a sex for sex list.

[.!WAR MIKEY!.]

NO not on a mixed P4P hell no, if they want to make her top 3 or number 1 on a all womens list than knock yourself out but on a mixed list she isnt even top 20 in the mens league.