BS P4P ranking poll

[YGriffith]

1)Canelo (best resume)
2)Usyk (undisputed)
3)Crawford (undisputed)
4)Lomachenko (Won a title in his 3rd fight)
5)Pacquiao

[Boxing Goat]

Canelo has far more elite wins then Usyk..GGG,Lara, Cotto are better then anyone Usyk has beaten

Lara? No, I don't think so and funny you mention him because Canelo may have lost to him too. As far as Cotto, he was very long in the tooth at that stage. And GGG beat him so you can give that up. Usyk is undefeated, never been close to losing and cleaned out the entire CW division, which Canelo has not done. I think the debate is very live there.

[Boxing Goat]

1)Canelo (best resume)
2)Usyk (undisputed)
3)Crawford (undisputed)
4)Lomachenko (Won a title in his 3rd fight)
5)Pacquiao

P4P is not based just on resume and if it was then Pacman would be #1.

Very poor P4P list I'm afraid.

[Michael1437]

For P4P, I would go with Crawford, with Loma a very very close 2nd.

[ruedboy]

I'm not surprised any more when fans say Canelo's resume is great and then go on to say Cotto is a top win.
If you just look at Cotto's record before he fought Canelo it's obvious Cotto was shot.
Going into the Alvarez fight, Cotto had lost to Magarito and Pac and both fights were beat downs.
Miguel was also in a war with Floyd, who almost stopped him. Finally he lost to Trout and that's Trout's only "good" win as Austin went on to lose to Alvarez, Williams, Hurd and both Charlos.
Cotto becoming MW champ, with his win over the one-legged Martinez, was all about clever match making and behind the scenes BS. IMO

[boliodogs]

To me it's Inoue. I don't think any other boxer is as vastly superior to any boxer his weight as In oue. He just crushes any boxer his weight. I can see the possibility of all the others losing a fight to another boxer in their current weight class except Inoue.

[Larry the boss]

Lara? No, I don't think so and funny you mention him because Canelo may have lost to him too. As far as Cotto, he was very long in the tooth at that stage. And GGG beat him so you can give that up. Usyk is undefeated, never been close to losing and cleaned out the entire CW division, which Canelo has not done. I think the debate is very live there.

canelo beat GGG and Lara and Cotto are better then anyone Loma or GGG or Crawford has beaten

[Boxing_1013]

Wow....

Ok, DQ'd from any real conversation about this.

Bye

Yeah I like that guy but that is a wild comment lol...Loma already has a top current resume and he has like 15 fights

[Boxing_1013]

canelo beat GGG and Lara and Cotto are better then anyone Loma or GGG or Crawford has beaten

Idk I saw GGG win both vs Nelo 8-4...good fights but each one with a clear winner imo.

Lara was a good 7-5 win imo for Nelo...but same type level as GGG's Jacobs or Murray win for me...and come on man...if GGG brought Cotto out right now and fought him how much credit would you give him if he stopped him?

Gotta take into account when/where/how what weight, what version, etc of that fighter that a guy beat.

GGG overall imo has been more impressive in his career than Nelo, even apart from those 2 fights...Nelo is a great fighter though I can't hate on him a bit.

And I mean how can you hype up Nelo's win over Cotto for example...but dismiss Loma's wins over Rigo and Walters...just not really keeping it real imo

[4truth]

canelo beat GGG and Lara and Cotto are better then anyone Loma or GGG or Crawford has beaten

Unless you didn't see it that way.