BS P4P ranking poll

[Pigeons]

I don't think that even makes him P4P#1 when he lost to GGG and yes, he lost to GGG.

I can see the boxing powers that be withholding that distinction from him until he fights Golovkin a third time. I'm not saying I agree with it, but I can see it.

[DuckAdonis]

You just DQ'd yourself from the topic

Remove the ginger cheat then and add Nietes. Im fine with it

[Redd Foxx]

It's Crawford and Loma. Canelo getting a stack of controversial decisions doesn't make him #1. Some complain that Loma has better names than Crawford but it's not just about resume, p4p includes the eye test for raw talent and Bud seems to be right there with Loma as the 2 most talented guys in the sport. I'd put Usyk not far behind, and above Canelo.

[Boxing Goat]

I can see the boxing powers that be withholding that distinction from him until he fights Golovkin a third time. I'm not saying I agree with it, but I can see it.

I think the first fight was a definite loss and in the second fight he barely managed a draw at best. I can't rank him P4P#1 with that hanging out there.
But he's still top 5 for me based on his resume.

[Boxing Goat]

It's Crawford and Loma. Canelo getting a stack of controversial decisions doesn't make him #1. Some complain that Loma has better names than Crawford but it's not just about resume, p4p includes the eye test for raw talent and Bud seems to be right there with Loma as the 2 most talented guys in the sport. I'd put Usyk not far behind, and above Canelo.

I can agree with that and yes, Crawford passes the eye test almost as well as Loma but that's been against lesser opponents. If he beat Spence, he would be the undisputed P4P#1 for me but he won't face him. I think he's worried about the size difference and to me, he should be.

[Zinowor]

Lomachenko by a mile.

Crawford, Canelo, GGG, none of them are on Loma's level and they never will be.

Not even Crawford. I'm not seeing the hunger from him. Loma has taken very big risks and put himself at a disadvantage several times just to prove to everyone how good he is and has made it very clear that he's doing all of this to be considered the greatest.

I'm not seeing the same devotion from Crawford. He will probably dilly dally around, get some good deals for fights, look good and move on. But Loma is looking to be TBE and that's a whole different ball game.

[Pigeons]

I think the first fight was a definite loss and in the second fight he barely managed a draw at best. I can't rank him P4P#1 with that hanging out there.
But he's still top 5 for me based on his resume.

I agreed with the final result of both fights. I scored the first fight 114-114 and the second fight 115-113 Canelo. Obviously the 118-110 scorecard from the first fight was miserable, but I agreed with the ultimate decision.

[Boxing Goat]

I agreed with the final result of both fights. I scored the first fight 114-114 and the second fight 115-113 Canelo. Obviously the 118-110 scorecard from the first fight was miserable, but I agreed with the ultimate decision.

I don't and most boxing experts including those that matter most don't either but it's good to know that you do.

[Larry the boss]

Usyk has a legit claim to being ranked over Canelo in my opinion as well. Canelo hasn't really decisively beaten a true elite in a while now.

Canelo has far more elite wins then Usyk..GGG,Lara, Cotto are better then anyone Usyk has beaten

[Boxing Goat]

Lomachenko by a mile.

Crawford, Canelo, GGG, none of them are on Loma's level and they never will be.

Not even Crawford. I'm not seeing the hunger from him. Loma has taken very big risks and put himself at a disadvantage several times just to prove to everyone how good he is and has made it very clear that he's doing all of this to be considered the greatest.

I'm not seeing the same devotion from Crawford. He will probably dilly dally around, get some good deals for fights, look good and move on. But Loma is looking to be TBE and that's a whole different ball game.

I agree with what you said, mostly. Crawford is selling himself short IMO. Loma is definitely becoming the best of this generation and that goes for his obvious skill and resume'. People saying that his resume' is thin are on straight up crack rock.