If Pacquiao beats Thurman he has to rank over Floyd historically

[travestyny]

- -PAC passed TUE 50-0 ages ago. Ring record holder in p4p stats by a long shot and smashed the multi division record in a breeze.

Nancys always gonna moan over cheap Prettyboys, so whatever.

But how many credible all-time lists can you find with Pac ranked over Mayweather.


Please point them out!

[pasawayako]

Pac is already way ahead of floyd.
8 division - 5 division
5 lineal - 3 lineal
FOTD - ?????

[pasawayako]

Pac beating Thurman will elevate Mayweather's win over Pac. Not only will it enhance pac's legacy but it will enhance mayweather's legacy as well.

If you are a super Pac fan and hate Mayweather then you better hope he loses to Thurman.

hahahaha. Floyd couldn't even hit pac cleanly and he's in survival mode against an injured pac.

[travestyny]

hahahaha. Floyd couldn't even hit pac cleanly and he's in survival mode against an injured pac.

But but but...you were sucking off Lomachenko hard when you thought he believed Pac won. You said he is the expert and he knows boxing.


But when he came out and said he made a mistake and Mayweather won 8-4....... You disowned him

[BoxingTrav]

floyd vs marquez = 12 rds dec
floyd vs oscar = 12 rds dec
floyd vs hatton = 10 rds tko
floyd vs molsey = 12 rds dec
floyd vs cotto = 12 rds dec


manny vs marquez 1,2,3,4 = 2 wins, 12 rds dec
manny vs oscar = 8 rds oscar quit
manny vs hatton = 2 rds ko!!
manny vs molsey = 12 rds dec
manny vs cotto = 12 rds tko

What are their records against common opponents?

[2Shotz]

They’re both fighters for The Ages. If anything Pac might have superior fighting heart over Floyd BUT I’m not even sure of that. Floyd immediately rematched Castillo and Maidana after their contests and the man is a perfect storm of family, talent, work ethic, promotional and business smarts. Haters gonna Hate. Love Pac too but I think Floyd edges him.

[hugh grant]

Lol. Common opponents. Mosely, Marquez, De La Hoya, Cotto, Hatton. Floyd is 5-0, Manny is 6-1-1. Tell me which record is better?

Second, Pac was not only knocked out early, he was knocked out by Marquez, dropped by Hussein by a jab, etc. Floyd though fighting hard punchers was never put down on the canvas.

You can use the fighting internationally card if you want, what top fighter did Manny fight abroad?

Lastly we can all agree that they are special fighters. But we have to dissect the careers to make
a claim for who's greater. Resume matters, Floyd is unbeaten, untied, never been on the canvas, has fought on a championship level since hus second year as a pro. He beat Pac head to head. He shut out a man that Pac fought life and death with. A man that put Pac to sleep.


This is clear to me

Pac should have 3 wins over JMM if not scorecard error. 3 wins is better than floyds cheated scales win. Even Pacs 2 wins is better than a cheated scales win.
Jmm said Pac is best of era.
Pacs so good and the standards are set so high that a young lion like Thurman is considered a cherry pick. Just cos Thurmans last performance wasn't so great? So next time NElo struggles in last fight I want Floyd to challenge him. If its easy beating people who struggle in last fight. Go on Floyd be a 6 division champ. Its that easy. JUst fight fighters coming off under par performances.

[KillaMane26]

I love Pac but alot of wins at 147 were against guys coming off losses. And that whole 7 division claim is about credible as Broner 2 division claim. But wins over prime Bradley were great.

[BoxingTrav]

Pac should have 3 wins over JMM if not scorecard error. 3 wins is better than floyds cheated scales win. Even Pacs 2 wins is better than a cheated scales win.
Jmm said Pac is best of era.
Pacs so good and the standards are set so high that a young lion like Thurman is considered a cherry pick. Just cos Thurmans last performance wasn't so great? So next time NElo struggles in last fight I want Floyd to challenge him. If its easy beating people who struggle in last fight. Go on Floyd be a 6 division champ. Its that easy. JUst fight fighters coming off under par performances.

Cheated scales win. Lol. What about the 4th fight? That was the L. That loss is something that Floyd never did against anyone including common opponents. Thus Floyd's record against common opponents is better. Thanks

[boogbx]

He already does, beating Thurman is for his personal Legacy because as a fighter he is an ATG already.