Ring Magazine once had Broner #6 P4P?

[Redsox]

If Pacquiao fought Mikey Garcia right now @ 140, Garcia gets stopped or quits inside of eight rounds after clearly losing five of them.

i hope u aint hittin da crack pipe. cuz dat is dumb

[Combat Talk Radio]

Highly doubt it, but everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

i hope u aint hittin da crack pipe. cuz dat is dumb

Garcia was taken the distance by, and never once hurt or wobbled, Adrien Broner.

Manny had Broner staggering all over the damn ring.

Mikey Garcia's weakness is a busy fighter with at least some power. Pacquiao is ALL WRONG for ya boy. You're overhyping him because of who he's fought so far - and his fight against Spence will highlight what I said. Mark it down and come back after that fight.

[CHOWWOKKA]

Well manny didn't have an official win in 2012 so... I could see that

[IronDanHamza]

Yeah Ring had Calzaghe #1 at SMW from 2003-2008. Its all on boxrec. Lacy was never #1.

He was never even #2.

He never even sniffed the P4P list.

But I suppose Calzaghe fans have to create false realities to attempt to enhance what was an extremely underwhelming career.

[lolpz]

Garcia was taken the distance by, and never once hurt or wobbled, Adrien Broner.

Manny had Broner staggering all over the damn ring.

Mikey Garcia's weakness is a busy fighter with at least some power. Pacquiao is ALL WRONG for ya boy. You're overhyping him because of who he's fought so far - and his fight against Spence will highlight what I said. Mark it down and come back after that fight.

Mikey's style is all wrong for Pac.

Pac has a better chance against Spence then Mikey does. Too much weight/skills/strength for Mikey to overcome.

Mikey can beat Pac tho.

[Redsox]

Garcia was taken the distance by, and never once hurt or wobbled, Adrien Broner.

Manny had Broner staggering all over the damn ring.

Mikey Garcia's weakness is a busy fighter with at least some power. Pacquiao is ALL WRONG for ya boy. You're overhyping him because of who he's fought so far - and his fight against Spence will highlight what I said. Mark it down and come back after that fight.

nah pacquiao might even get kod like sometimes happens with him

[Combat Talk Radio]

nah pacquiao might even get kod like sometimes happens with him

Mikey's style is all wrong for Pac.

Pac has a better chance against Spence then Mikey does. Too much weight/skills/strength for Mikey to overcome.

Mikey can beat Pac tho.

Like I said before. Mark down the thread and come back after the Spence fight. And I don't want to hear excuses about weight, either.

People think I hate Manny - I don't. I have no respect for him since he ducked The Hornet rematch, but I don't hate the guy. I do know this: A 40-year old Manny Pacquiao makes short, quick work of Mikey Garcia and VERY likely causes him to pull a Naseem Hamed/Michael Spinks - retire after that one loss in disgrace.

[warrenchico]

I remember Brandon Rios being in the top 10 P4P list when he was dominating the 140 division

[soul_survivor]

And this is why I always argue with buffoons on here who say P4P is all about the "eye test" as opposed to resume and skills displayed against top competition. The eye test is pure nonsense and why guys like Broner get hyped up.

I think the eye test still stands as one of the ways of looking at a fighter but obviously competition and manner of wins should be taken into account.

With Broner, however, it was entirely different. The various groups involved in making the p4p lists did so purely on the basis of wanting to promote Broner as the new American star, even though they saw him barely get past PDL and Malignaggi.

[soul_survivor]

I remember Brandon Rios being in the top 10 P4P list when he was dominating the 140 division

Ah, that is another ridiculous ranking I forgot