Is Sugar Shane an All-Time Great?

[AREALFIGHTER]

Scarlett Johansson did well in {The Horse Whisperer} but i think she lacks depth in her rolls . I would like to see her move up and have about 5 films a year before i would call her an all time great . If she can beat out a Julia Roberts for a few rolls she moves into the top movie stars P4P.

Funniest thing I have heard in a while thanks for the laught, karma

[yrrej]

He's nothing special....

[sers2k]

fallen off short...

[DiegoFuego]

Two words: Scarlett Johansson

42 more: He had the ability to be an all time great but he's too old to take over the division now and his losses to Winky and Forrest wont help. Losing to ODLH in many people's eyes definitely doesn't help his cause either.

Agree agree agree. Mosley's a cool enough cat, a little stubborn in stampeding into those rematches although it probably would not have mattered. Felt bad for him until he got his money matches vs. Vargas. Mosley should retire soon and enjoy it as a great fighter, but not an all-time great.

[Mr. Ryan]

Mosley is a guy who got to the pinnacle of the sport behind the strength of his accomplishments as a lightweight. To be honest, he was never impressive at welterweight and up, except for the first DLH fight. I remember when people were saying he was unbeatable, and I knew immediately that Forrest was gonna beat the living **** out of him.

Mosley has no boxing skill, just reflexes and experience. He doesn't know how to jab effectively, just kinda paws with the right hand to set up a right. He never impressed me with his technique, but his willingness to fight and strength were stuff you couldn't ignore. While he does have two wins over De La Hoya, those two fights essentially represent all that he's done this decade. I think he's an HOF, but not first ballot. I always thought of him as more a fan favorite than a great fighter.

[Piggu]

yes Shane Mosley should be an all time great

Should Be?

[aljon]

Shane defenetly deserves an all-time great in history

[aljon]

He's nothing special....

You're an ignorant.

[dino]

At 135 Yes

[Abe Attell]

all time great naw, 1-1 with de la hoya, lost 4 times to forrest n wright. beat vargas, dont sound to hall of fame 2 m3

So what, there are a number of "All time great" fighters that when they moved up in weight they lost.

If somebody that stays at one weight class their entire career can be called an "All time great", why should we think different of somebody that was undefeated and a machine at his original world championship weight, but decided to move up?