Is Sugar Shane an All-Time Great?

[flipside]

he aint sugar for nothing but scarlett johansonn is p4p #1!

[jason100x]

He is a great fighter but I need to see where the rest of career will go before I fully call him an all time great.

[THE REAL NINJA]

ok ..what he did at lightweight makes him an all time great IMO with the skill speed power and size he has i see no reason he wouldnt give a good fight to SRR Duran or any other greats so yes i do

[DANGER13]

all time great naw, 1-1 with de la hoya, lost 4 times to forrest n wright. beat vargas, dont sound to hall of fame 2 m3

[eyeloveboxing]

he won 1 great fight with DLH, thats about it... that was a bad match up for Oscar. good fighter, yes but all time great? i dont think so... its a shame to put "Sugar" in front of his name...

[shambo]

Hell yes, definitely a great. Scarlett Johansson too though!

[Southpaw16]

So Scarlett Johanssen is now leading this poll. I'm speechless...

[THE REAL NINJA]

So Scarlett Johanssen is now leading this poll. I'm speechless...

i could take her in 5 rounds

[realheavyhands]

he should of never lifted weights and moved up in weight so high, if you learned how to dance instead of lifting he could of been one of the greatest

[TheEvilSaint]

is he good: very.
is he great: sort of.
is he an all time great: no.