Comments Thread For: Menayothin Goes For 51-0 on August 28, May Pass Mayweather

[elfag]

Definitely an impressive resume, but it looks a lot better than than it actually is. I think the main reason people dismiss a lot of these victories is because of the way Floyd won most of these fights. He was ultra defensive and pretty boring. Coupled with the reasons below, it puts Floyd's resume into perspective.

Maidana, Judah (lost to Khan, enough said)
Gatti, De La Hoya, Pacquiao, Mosley, Cotto (all well past their primes),
Canelo (before his prime)
Marquez (moved up 2 weight classes)
Ortiz (come on, he's never been good)
Hernandez (really?)

Guerrero was a good win. But Guerrero turned out to be pretty one dimensional.

Best wins were Hatton and Corrales.

Youre saying Judah isnt a good win because he lost to Khan? WTF, do you realize that was 5 YEARS later? If youre going to criticize the Judah win, atleast say its because he lost to Baldomir.

And the Guerrero win is a bigger deal to you than the Hernandez win? Why that doesnt even make sense. how long have you been following boxing? You get that was his first lineal title right? And Guerrero hadnt dont **** and never did end up doing ****.

[champion4ever]

What can you say? The man is an all-time great.