Who ranks higher p4p of all time Bhop, Roy Jones or Pacquiao?

[Illmatic94]

UMM because he easily beat him in his prime. EASY EASY WIN. And he went from 160 and won a hw title. LOL you're clueless.

umm Hopkins was not in his prime in 1993. sorry. now when Bhop was calling for the rematch around 2002-2003 at that point they were both really in their primes. but Roy didn't want none.

and James Toney had to shed like 18-20 lbs with four days before the Jones weigh in. he was so drained he was hooked to an IV.

these two wins are overrated.

the best win Roy had in the 90's was Montell Griffin.

[John Locke]

Pacman, Jones, Hopkins

[bojangles1987]

There's no valid argument to put Hopkins above Jones jr at all.

Seriously. I really hate the persistent push to do so just because of Hopkins's longevity. Even with all that longevity, he didn't beat better fighters or accomplish as much as Roy. Roy's clearly the greater fighter.

[bojangles1987]

People severely overvalue Hopkins's career to put him ahead of either Jones or Pacquiao. Those two beat much better fighters than him and accomplished more. Hopkins's longevity doesn't matter if it doesn't result in greater accomplishments or wins over better fighters. You can't just say "longevity" and think that means anything.

[NoConcoms]

Hopkins.

Simply because he's never been linked to PED use.

[Laddie_Loc]

Pac
Jones























Soapy.

[djtmal]

Manny is far ahead of Jones man

As far as names yeah

You can look at it a couple of ways but beating 2 prime atgs seals it for me. Toney was undefeated, and Hopkins 1 loss

[IronDanHamza]

Lets list their best wins

Manny

Barrera
Morales
Cotto
Jmm

those his top 4 IMO

now list the others top 4 wins

Hopkins
Toney
Tarver
Griffin

Now what's Hopkins?

[Johnny2x2x]

RJJ is probably top 15 all time and that's because he had a prime where he was maybe the most talented to ever lace em up.

Pacquaio is top 35 all time, champ in 8 divisions, fought some legends and beat some of the best.

Hopkins is top 40 All time, had a long career, just didn't dominate opponents as much as some other greats.

[IronDanHamza]

umm Hopkins was not in his prime in 1993. sorry. now when Bhop was calling for the rematch around 2002-2003 at that point they were both really in their primes. but Roy didn't want none.

and James Toney had to shed like 18-20 lbs with four days before the Jones weigh in. he was so drained he was hooked to an IV.

these two wins are overrated.

the best win Roy had in the 90's was Montell Griffin.

Roy didn't want none yet Hopkins turned down the offer.

Do you have a source for Toney needing to shed 20 lbs in 4 days and that he was hooked up to an IV?

And how was his weight for Jones any different to any of his other weight cuts?