>>> LOSING to Orlando Salido excludes you from P4P #1 status when...

[Nay_Sayer]

Get over it.

It's not that deep.

He's the best fighter alive you'll just have to accept it.

RJJ
Floyd Mayweather
Andre Ward
Sugar Ray Leonard
Thomas Hearns
Marvin Hagler
Roberto Duran

Are all still ALIVE, Einstein...

[KingTito]

That’s not how this works.

[Nay_Sayer]

but if you’re really wanting to question convince an entire forum what Crawford has done that Loma has not.

Easy.

Remain *undefeated*.

[xhiddenx87]

Do this guy knows about Manny pacquiao? A guy with losses early on his record and then got to the top of P4P list.
Oh look thread fail!

[Chuckguy]

... Guys like Terrance Crawford and Mikey Garcia are UNDEFEATED. You want to be P4P #1? Beat one of those guys and the argument will be put to rest.

And please, SAVE the excuses. The LOSS was legit...

Valid points but you can also argue who did mikey or Crawford fight in their first 8 pro fights that was as experienced and dangerous as salido?
I’ll help you
NONE
NO ONE
so that kinda puts the argument to a reset doesn’t it?

[Nay_Sayer]

Do this guy knows about Manny pacquiao? A guy with losses early on his record and then got to the top of P4P list.
Oh look thread fail!

Pacquiao has wins over Juan Manuel Marquez, Marco Antonio Barrera, and Miguel Cotto.

Exactly WHO has Lomafako beaten?

[chrisJS]

RJJ
Floyd Mayweather
Andre Ward
Sugar Ray Leonard
Thomas Hearns
Marvin Hagler
Roberto Duran

Are all still ALIVE, Einstein...

Leonard 3 losses, Hearns 5 losses, Hagler 3 losses, Duran 16 losses, Roy Jones 8 losses (brutal ones by some bums too) so according to tie casuals mentality about losses meaning you can't fight you can't qualify those guys.

Your rules would suggest GGG, Wilder, Joshua are all FAR better than those guys.

[Nay_Sayer]

Valid points but you can also argue who did mikey or Crawford fight in their first 8 pro fights that was as experienced and dangerous as salido?
I’ll help you
NONE
NO ONE
so that kinda puts the argument to a reset doesn’t it?

No.

Crawford beat his Salido level opponents.

Garcia literally beat Salido.

Lomafako, OTOH, never bothered to avenge the LOSS.

Beating the likes of GRJ and Jorge Linares isn't enough to warrant P4P #1 status when A) you LOSE to the like of Orlando Salido and B) guys like Terrance Crawford and Mikey Garcia are *undefeated*.

1 + 1 = 2

[chrisJS]

Easy.

Remain *undefeated*.

Calzaghe > Roy Jones?

He kicked his ass and was unbeaten.

Calzaghe > Hopkins?

[Nay_Sayer]

Leonard 3 losses, Hearns 5 losses, Hagler 3 losses, Duran 16 losses, Roy Jones 8 losses (brutal ones by some bums too) so according to tie casuals mentality about losses meaning you can't fight you can't qualify those guys.

Your rules would suggest GGG, Wilder, Joshua are all FAR better than those guys.

So, are you arguing that Lomachenko is better than Leonard, Hearns, Hagler, Duran, and RJJ?