Why is Winky so high on peoples P4P list

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • GreatestIam
    GreatestIam
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Apr 2006
    • 3392
    • 215
    • 53
    • 11,504

    #1

    Why is Winky so high on peoples P4P list

    I dont understand why this guy is ranked #3 on most p4p list, it seems that after beating Mosley twice and a BLOWN_UP WACK version of the Felix Trinidad most people came to love (when he was KOing MOFOs) the guy skyrocketed to the top, i dont understand it!

    If you look at his resume despite his 50 wins the guys he has faced are basically namless nobodies, this includes his 3 losses (Vargas is, was and will always be overrated,JCV was good for like a second and well Simon could have been a major force but ....)! It seems to me that the TRINIDAD fight left this impression that he was a GREAT FIGHTER, and even with that TRINIDAD had already gotten his block knocked-off and came back to fight Wright after fighting two defensivless BUMS!

    I mean Wright has a great defense, YES and can beat up on guys smaller then him YES, but what has he really done other then beating GUYS naturally smaller then him to be #3 or higher on P4P list?

    The fact is this SAT he will be exposed for the SUB_PAR fighter he is and i wouldnt be surprised if after the fight, he drains himself and goes back to the roll of bullying little people!

    I mean it was evident in the Soliman fight that he will have major trouble fighting at MW with guys his size and his strength, and even in that fight he was the bigger man(he was 171 Sam was 158), what do you think his gonna do when he comes in at say 170-174 and Taylor comes in a little bigger then that?

    I just cant wait to see him exposed and played_out as a guy who can only beat little people, and after SAT he should be earased from any top 10 rankings, unless he does convert down to a lower weight and back to beating little people up, then and only then could he be put back on a P4P list! (I mean you dont hear JT's name being mentioned as fighting say a PBF haha well Wrights naturally 170+ ass is being mentioned as fighting him and that doesn make any ****ing sense, HIS A LITTLE PEOPLE BEATER, PEOPLE, NOTHING ELSE) HE GETS HIS ASS KOed ON SAT
    Last edited by GreatestIam; 06-14-2006, 12:25 AM.
  • Newportz
    Contender
    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
    • Jun 2006
    • 131
    • 9
    • 3
    • 6,350

    #2
    Mosley has only had trouble w/ 2 fighters in his career...Winky and Vernon...You beat Shane twice, you deserve credit...

    He destroyed Felix....bad....

    We'll see what happens in the Taylor fight...If Wink wins, he deserves all credit given...If Taylor wins, then you dont have to worry about Wright in the P4P rankings...

    Comment

    • GreatestIam
      GreatestIam
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Apr 2006
      • 3392
      • 215
      • 53
      • 11,504

      #3
      Originally posted by Newportz
      Mosley has only had trouble w/ 2 fighters in his career...Winky and Vernon...You beat Shane twice, you deserve credit...

      He destroyed Felix....bad....

      We'll see what happens in the Taylor fight...If Wink wins, he deserves all credit given...If Taylor wins, then you dont have to worry about Wright in the P4P rankings...
      Yes Mosley had trouble with Vernon thats a given he had Shanes number, and well Wright had Mosleys little ass out weighed watch the fights... Beat Shane twice and well Vernon didnt get any crdit on the P4P list and thats before he got his ass KOed by MAYORGA....

      He destroyed Felix ok... **** B_Hop destroyed Felix's career.. Winky just destroyed the man

      and i GUARENTEE TAYLOR WHOOPS HIS ASS, and even with those 3 wins that doesnt give anyone in the world the right to be put so high on the P4P list

      Comment

      • Dirt E Gomez
        ***Stupendous***
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Jul 2005
        • 9976
        • 952
        • 1,092
        • 18,863

        #4
        The only obvious reason is because you are too hard on him. You can make arguments for and against every fighter who is on the p4p list but it's still ultimately opinion. I could discredit any fighter you list with certain facts, but that simply means I'm usually being biased against them. You're simply putting a higher standard on Winky than the rest of the list. Nothing more, nothing less.

        Comment

        • fabzmm
          Banned
          • Apr 2006
          • 1050
          • 81
          • 0
          • 1,195

          #5
          Winky beat Vargas. And Vargas is not a small man. He was backing Vargas down all night and he was robbed. Plain and simple.

          He beat Mosley twice. He's not the same at 154, but dont get it twisted he still hits hard at 154. And that 2nd fight Winky was facing a HUNGRY shane with his career on the line and still won.

          He beat Tito.

          He was sick for the soliman fight. Do you really think he took him seriously?

          Comment

          • moy22487
            The silent poster
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Oct 2005
            • 3257
            • 99
            • 51
            • 9,856

            #6
            Originally posted by GreatestIAM
            Yes Mosley had trouble with Vernon thats a given he had Shanes number, and well Wright had Mosleys little ass out weighed watch the fights... Beat Shane twice and well Vernon didnt get any crdit on the P4P list and thats before he got his ass KOed by MAYORGA....

            He destroyed Felix ok... **** B_Hop destroyed Felix's career.. Winky just destroyed the man

            and i GUARENTEE TAYLOR WHOOPS HIS ASS, and even with those 3 wins that doesnt give anyone in the world the right to be put so high on the P4P list
            the fact that he hasnt lose in a long time.. his las one was the BS decision againts vargas. he never avoids anybody. that gives him p4p props. just because he is not exciting dont mean he is not a good boxer

            Comment

            • Bonafide
              The General
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • May 2006
              • 2233
              • 72
              • 35
              • 9,032

              #7
              He was clearly the most unappreciated Junior Middle at the time he beat Mosely. Alot of fighters avoided him including Oscar who not give him an opportinity. Beating Mosely twice and Trinidad would constitute p4p status , both guys beat Delahoya anyhow.

              Comment

              • Newportz
                Contender
                Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                • Jun 2006
                • 131
                • 9
                • 3
                • 6,350

                #8
                ^Exactly..........

                Comment

                • moy22487
                  The silent poster
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Oct 2005
                  • 3257
                  • 99
                  • 51
                  • 9,856

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Bonafide
                  He was clearly the most unappreciated Junior Middle at the time he beat Mosely. Alot of fighters avoided him including Oscar who not give him an opportinity. Beating Mosely twice and Trinidad would constitute p4p status , both guys beat Delahoya anyhow.
                  completely difrent styles. maybe oscar would of given winky a harder fight. in my book he should have a vicotry over tito and mosely

                  Comment

                  • Bonafide
                    The General
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • May 2006
                    • 2233
                    • 72
                    • 35
                    • 9,032

                    #10
                    Originally posted by fabzmm
                    Winky beat Vargas. And Vargas is not a small man. He was backing Vargas down all night and he was robbed. Plain and simple.

                    He beat Mosley twice. He's not the same at 154, but dont get it twisted he still hits hard at 154. And that 2nd fight Winky was facing a HUNGRY shane with his career on the line and still won.

                    He beat Tito.

                    He was sick for the soliman fight. Do you really think he took him seriously?

                    robbed ? Vargas deserved to win that fight. Wright took the last 3 rounds off and Vargas pressed the action. Its ludicrous to call that a robbery.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP