If M.Garcia Becomes 4 Weight Champ after Lipinets, Does He Become P4P #1?

[THEFRESHBRAWLER]

...anyone but loma or ggg.

Lmaoo why?

[turnedup]

Not unless we are willing to retroactively designate Broner as #1 for fighting the weakest champions in their divisions.

[TheBigLug]

To be top p4p, i think you have to beat a fighter that is arguably a p4p fighter. Which of Garcia's opponents all into that catagory? not even close, they're not even the next best in their division usually, or not for a while anyway.

Ward beating Kovalev is how you get there. The winner of GGG v Canelo would have a claim to it. Something along those lines. I rate Garcia highly and he's doing good things but let's see him fight a real A level fighter.

[j0zef]

Do you think that Mikey inherited Broner's P4P #1 4 weight class champ crown?

[NYG]

Guy has 13 fights. Mikey should run through him with no problem. Should be a stepping stone to a bigger fight

[TheCell8]

How good is Lipinets? Not very...

[bluebeam]

To be top p4p, i think you have to beat a fighter that is arguably a p4p fighter. Which of Garcia's opponents all into that catagory? not even close, they're not even the next best in their division usually, or not for a while anyway.

Ward beating Kovalev is how you get there. The winner of GGG v Canelo would have a claim to it. Something along those lines. I rate Garcia highly and he's doing good things but let's see him fight a real A level fighter.

would a win over somebody like lomachenko be good enough?

[TheBigLug]

would a win over somebody like lomachenko be good enough?

of course.

Whoever wins that fight if it happens has a serious claim to p4p no.1. obviously people will bring weight into it but they shouldn't. Loma believes he beats Garcia so that's good enough for me if Mikey wins.

[Taxman2000]

...anyone but loma or ggg.

Lol MIkey Garcia isn’t even top 10.he hasn’t fought anyone elite mikey is on a bum wiping tour

[bluebeam]

of course.

Whoever wins that fight if it happens has a serious claim to p4p no.1. obviously people will bring weight into it but they shouldn't. Loma believes he beats Garcia so that's good enough for me if Mikey wins.

i agree!!!!