Comments Thread For: A New Number One: BoxingScene Pound-for-Pound Update

[The Big Dunn]

Crawford clearly is #1. I would have Mikey or Loma then GGG at #4. I think GGG is a little high but I can see moving him up if you gave him the win over Canelo.

TBRB rankings are what I go by and they have Crawford 1 and GGG 2 as well.

[koolkc107]

In one breath, you say a guy needs to beat a P4P.

You then post a list that excludes the ONE guy who beat a P4P in everyone else's eyes.

Explain that.

When Buster Douglas upset Tyson, I don't think he wound up on the next P4P list.

I thought hard about Rungvisai (as well as Estrada) and decided I needed to see more before they make this list.

But yeah, point taken.

[aboutfkntime]

Ok refresh my memory
Why should Spence be ranked who has he beat? Why are ggg and canelo even in the top 5? How is mikey on the list?

to answer ALL of those questions.....

P4P has nothing to do with resume'

this happens every single month, without fail

[aboutfkntime]

Spence is my man but he can't be put on here till he beats another 1/2 top ww's. I feel the Brook fight was a good win, Brook was on top early on he managed to weather storms and break him mentally.

he can be put on there if you are good enough to rank him

it is your list

[aboutfkntime]

crazy having Golovkin ranked #2

he has campaigned at middleweight his entire career..... and now that he finally stepped up in class, we can see that he is not dominant

even Spence looks more dominant than Golovkin, and he has a better win

I would still rank chocolatito ahead of Golovkin..... because he only struggled when he stepped up another weight class, and only against one fighter..... with the main problem seeming to be that he looks stretched at SFW

I want to see Gonzales drop back down in weight, and would need to at least see him lose/struggle to someone else before I determine that he has slipped/faded sufficiently enough to rank him lower than somebody with less quality wins, especially since that guy is struggling with fighters in his natural weight class

I would have Spence listed for the reasons above

[Boxing Goat]

Funny. A 1 pt. win over Jacobs and a draw against Canelo apparently makes you the best in the world. The man has been at MW his entire career but hasn't won the lineal title or unified all 4 belts. Crawford has won the lineal title in 2 weight classes and unified all 4 belts in 1 weight class.

Apparently you don't know how to score fights because I gave Canelo and Jacobs a max of 4 rounds each so that argument is useless. I don't care what the score cards say, experts know what happened in those fights.

[Boxing Goat]

@ Golovkin fans saying Crawford beat nobody, who has Golovkin beaten? ****ing Jacobs? These clowns were claiming Golovkin was #1 before he even fought Jacobs too.

Jacobs is better than anyone Crawford has beaten. Stop fooling yourself.

[Pigeons]

Apparently you don't know how to score fights because I gave Canelo and Jacobs a max of 4 rounds each so that argument is useless. I don't care what the score cards say, experts know what happened in those fights.

http://www.boxingscene.com/scorecards/Gennady-Golovkin-vs-Daniel-Jacobs--65

http://www.boxingscene.com/scorecards/Canelo-Alvarez-vs-Gennady-Golovkin--97

[Boxing Goat]

http://www.boxingscene.com/scorecard...iel-Jacobs--65

http://www.boxingscene.com/scorecard...y-Golovkin--97

Oh.....I see, are you one the Boxingscene scoring panel? lol

Judges' Scores: 114-113, 115-112, 115-112 for Golovkin

Those were closer to reality and as you know, everyone in the world had Canelo losing to GGG except the official judges and apparently now I see Boxingscene. Laughable

[koolkc107]

he can be put on there if you are good enough to rank him

it is your list

I definitely feel good enough.

I had Mikey Garcia on my P4P top ten list quite a bit before he started appearing on official lists.

I felt that strongly about it then.

I feel that way about Spence now.

Besides, along with Brook, you cannot ignore what Errol has done to common opponents of other top guys.

ex. Lo Greco went 10 with Porter while Errol stopped him in 3; Bundu went the distance with Thurman but couldn't finish 6 against Spence; Algieri tumbled thru 12 with Pac but was stopped in less than 5 against Strap Season.

Errol is for real, the heir to Floyd and Pac.