Just rewatched and scored it. Please stop crying. No robbery.

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Vlad_
    Banned
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • May 2017
    • 13968
    • 3,241
    • 1,478
    • 836,213

    #41
    Originally posted by Golden Boi 360
    1. Canelo
    2. Canelo
    3. Canelo
    4. Golovkin ***
    5. Golovkin ***
    6. Canelo ***
    7. Golovkin (clearest round in the whole fight in my opinion)
    8. Golovkin
    9. Canelo ***
    10. Golovkin
    11. Golovkin
    12. Canelo

    6-6, 114-114.
    So according to you the first three which were extremely close you put as clear Canelo, but 4-5-6 which were clear GGG rounds you put as close, and even gave 6 to Canelo?

    Comment

    • Johnny2x2x
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Aug 2013
      • 2279
      • 263
      • 44
      • 18,765

      #42
      Originally posted by Vlad_
      So according to you the first three which were extremely close you put as clear Canelo, but 4-5-6 which were clear GGG rounds you put as close, and even gave 6 to Canelo?
      I scored 5 and 6 for Canelo and they seemed pretty clear for him to me.

      Comment

      • Golden Boi 360
        Boxing's Biggest Cash Cow
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • May 2010
        • 5724
        • 402
        • 318
        • 86,855

        #43
        Originally posted by Vlad_
        So according to you the first three which were extremely close you put as clear Canelo, but 4-5-6 which were clear GGG rounds you put as close, and even gave 6 to Canelo?
        If I put an asterik I think they're close and could have gone either way.

        If I didn't, then I think one guy did slightly better work and deserved it.

        This fight was full of close rounds. Looking at other people's scorecards no one can really agree that one guy 100% deserved a round. Scorecards are all over the place.

        Comment

        • Scipio2009
          Undisputed Champion
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Apr 2014
          • 13741
          • 276
          • 64
          • 98,172

          #44
          Originally posted by Golden Boi 360
          not sure if you're being sarcastic or not lol
          Being completely legit; didn't watch the fight (was flying back home), so simply going off of what the post I was responding to scored the fight.

          If a round is close, logic says that the edge usually goes to whatever style the person scoring prefers.

          Unless you're trying to argue that Golovkin or Alvarez simply clearly dominated more rounds than folks are talking about, I'm not sure where your surprise is coming from.

          Comment

          • Golden Boi 360
            Boxing's Biggest Cash Cow
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • May 2010
            • 5724
            • 402
            • 318
            • 86,855

            #45
            Originally posted by Scipio2009
            Being completely legit; didn't watch the fight (was flying back home), so simply going off of what the post I was responding to scored the fight.

            If a round is close, logic says that the edge usually goes to whatever style the person scoring prefers.

            Unless you're trying to argue that Golovkin or Alvarez simply clearly dominated more rounds than folks are talking about, I'm not sure where your surprise is coming from.
            Okay, that's cool. I thought you were being sarcastic or something.

            Yeah, I think many preferred Golovkin's pressure style even if he wasn't landing cleanly

            Comment

            • j0zef
              Undisputed Champion
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Oct 2015
              • 8421
              • 638
              • 767
              • 45,501

              #46
              I didn't watch the fight again yet, but your score is fine. Close fight or a draw are fair. The problem is that 118-110 card by Byrd that put do much controversy on the judging. It's really marring what was a great, great fight.

              Mad props to both fighters.

              Comment

              • Teetotaler
                Banned
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • May 2014
                • 8434
                • 274
                • 404
                • 18,146

                #47
                Originally posted by SilverMiles
                How you feel about all the judges awarding Canelo all the championship rounds even though you gave 2 of them to Golovkin.

                Is there nothing strange about that you?
                Lmfao danm you got him right there

                Comment

                • hateinyaeyes32
                  Undisputed Champion
                  • Feb 2010
                  • 1095
                  • 63
                  • 32
                  • 7,671

                  #48
                  Originally posted by Golden Boi 360
                  Sometimes boxing fans are their own worst enemies. They watch the fights as one big round, don't keep scorecards, and then like to cry when the decision is announced. This isn't surprising, there are people that think Floyd lost to Maidana and Pacquiao. Probably the same people that think Kovalev-Ward I was a robbery.

                  Unfortunately, people see one guy coming forward and assume he deserves to win.

                  Anyway, here is my scorecard. Watched it with no audio so I wouldn't be influenced. *** means that the round was close and could have gone either way. Canelo was throwing the combos, landed the eye catching shots, and better body shots. Golovkin applied the non-stop pressure.

                  Neither guy was hurt, dropped, bloodied, battered or took significant damage. Rounds were close. Cries of robbery uncalled for.

                  1. Canelo
                  2. Canelo
                  3. Canelo
                  4. Golovkin ***
                  5. Golovkin ***
                  6. Canelo ***
                  7. Golovkin (clearest round in the whole fight in my opinion)
                  8. Golovkin
                  9. Canelo ***
                  10. Golovkin
                  11. Golovkin
                  12. Canelo

                  6-6, 114-114.
                  Your name is golden boy and your profile pic is Canelo punching GGG.... Your whole post wasn't even worth reading due to the fact

                  Comment

                  • tokon
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 7641
                    • 1,826
                    • 1,286
                    • 42,234

                    #49
                    Originally posted by Golden Boi 360
                    Sometimes boxing fans are their own worst enemies. They watch the fights as one big round, don't keep scorecards, and then like to cry when the decision is announced. This isn't surprising, there are people that think Floyd lost to Maidana and Pacquiao. Probably the same people that think Kovalev-Ward I was a robbery.

                    Unfortunately, people see one guy coming forward and assume he deserves to win.

                    Anyway, here is my scorecard. Watched it with no audio so I wouldn't be influenced. *** means that the round was close and could have gone either way. Canelo was throwing the combos, landed the eye catching shots, and better body shots. Golovkin applied the non-stop pressure.

                    Neither guy was hurt, dropped, bloodied, battered or took significant damage. Rounds were close. Cries of robbery uncalled for.

                    1. Canelo
                    2. Canelo
                    3. Canelo
                    4. Golovkin ***
                    5. Golovkin ***
                    6. Canelo ***
                    7. Golovkin (clearest round in the whole fight in my opinion)
                    8. Golovkin
                    9. Canelo ***
                    10. Golovkin
                    11. Golovkin
                    12. Canelo

                    6-6, 114-114.
                    Yes, I scored rounds slightly different but I got 6-6 too!

                    The one judge's scorecard was ridiculous but the overall DRAW decision wasn't.

                    115-113 for either guy would not have been a robbery.

                    Comment

                    • Sugar Adam Ali
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • Apr 2013
                      • 27630
                      • 970
                      • 1,174
                      • 82,827

                      #50
                      6-6 draw

                      Canelo had first 3 rds
                      Golovkin took control from 4-9
                      Canelo rallied and won the last 3..

                      Honestly pretty easy fight to score..
                      1,3,10 were close.. ggg gets one of those rds, he wins


                      I see no credible argument for canelo winning, but a draw is legit

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP