Who had more potential Zab,Broner or Gamboa?

[bluebeam]

Cory Spinks was essentially a journeyman WHEN JUDAH FOUGHT HIM. Yes.

Witter was basically a bum when Judah fought him. Constantly going the distance, two draws...LOL...then fought a bunch of setups until he ran into a brick wall named Timothy Bradley.

Bradley fought Witter at Witter's peak. THAT is a decisive win.


Let's try this again. Name a fighter - SEASONED FIGHTER - that Zab Judah beat IN THEIR PRIME, DECISIVELY, that is a better fighter than Antonio DeMarco. You won't find any.

Judah either beat them when they were bums, beat them when they were journeymen, or got beat by them.

zab fought Witter before Bradley did. so wtf are you talking about?

and demarco is a bum that has no wins on his resume.

matthysse > demarco

[b00g13man]

Cory Spinks was essentially a journeyman WHEN JUDAH FOUGHT HIM. Yes.

Ummmm....he most certainly wasn't. What the hell sort of alternate universe are you living in?

[King Jaffe Joffer]

I think Zab clearly.
Broner at his best wouldnt be able to compete with top welters, hes too small and doesnt throw enough punches.

Gamboa was a midget

Zab has chin and heart issues.. but his power and handspeed was a problem, he could box as well.

[Lester Tutor]

What affected Gamboa was his ego and not being mentally strong to compose himself. When he fought guys, his mannerisms and approach to their offense was always patronizing, especially in the Crawford bout in not owning up to his mistakes. Too much ego and pride that he let himself get hit thinking he could take TC's punches that inevitably did prolonging damage, mentally, the confidence... his skills and reflexes were always dope! the 50 Cent venture was a horrible thing to do

[WesternChamp]

judah no doubt!

[WesternChamp]

if zab have heart he would be a great fighter and one that will be hard to beat. but this fool always fold under pressure. this dude is a 5 round fighter.

[Combat Talk Radio]

Ummmm....he most certainly wasn't. What the hell sort of alternate universe are you living in?

Name one good fighter Cory Spinks had a win over BY THE TIME JUDAH FOUGHT HIM. I'll wait.

[Combat Talk Radio]

zab fought Witter before Bradley did. so wtf are you talking about?

That's what I said - Zab fought a Witter that wasn't fully cooked. Bradley beat the best Witter possible. It's not comparable.

[Combat Talk Radio]

Admit,, you didn't even watch boxing then..



Cory spinks was a "PAPER CHAMPION" at welter..

He only beat mayorga who beat Vernon Forrest who was the undisputed king of the welters.. this was the real deal title, but you would know that if you watched back then

Triangle theory bro.

First of all, had it not been for the point deductions the fight would likely have been a draw. In fact one judge HAD it a draw. The judge that had it wide was on crack.

Second of all, Spinks getting knocked down in the 12th not called a knockdown despite coming off three punches?

Third, Spinks basically threw the last two rounds and was getting roughed up for his trouble.

Fourth, Spinks constantly ducking was what caused him to get hit behind the head, it wasn't intentional.

Mayorga should have won that fight, or at least a draw. And Spinks looked bare average.

I find it funny people think Ward won the first Kov fight despite that fight largely going the same way as Mayorga/Spinks except for extra knockdowns on even rounds.

[b00g13man]

Name one good fighter Cory Spinks had a win over BY THE TIME JUDAH FOUGHT HIM. I'll wait.

What's with the shouting, and what the hell does that have to do with being a journeyman?

Do you even know what a journeyman is? You do know he had a unification fight with Mayorga, and became the lineal champion, before beating Zab, right?