Who had more potential Zab,Broner or Gamboa?

[All in]

Zab had the most tools and the most potential in my opinion

Coin toss on zab and Gamboa Leaning towards gamboa because zab was weak between the ears. Broner was just good. Nowhere near as talented as those 2.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Name one guy better than DeMarco on Judah's DECISIVE win list. And don't you dare say Cory Spinks who was a straight up journeyman when they fought.

Cory spinks was a journeymen??

Judah also beat witter which is much more impressive than beating demarco

[CatchAndShoot]

At some point you people need to understand that a fighter's job is to NOT allow their opponent to do that to them. We need to stop whining about roughhouse tactics, Mills Lane is retired and ill. Those days are gone.

Don't want to get wrestled? Do something about it. He didn't. Manny didn't. Choco didn't. That's their fault.

"No matter how...you...cut it, slice it or weigh it, he LOST to Ricky Hatton."

Listen, I'm not against a little clinch work, and rough house tactics on the inside, because I do agree that you have to know how to combat it, and even do it yourself, but what Hatton did wasn't normal boxing grappling, and clinching. He was on some UFC ish for that fight.

[Combat Talk Radio]

Cory spinks was a journeymen??

Judah also beat witter which is much more impressive than beating demarco

Cory Spinks was essentially a journeyman WHEN JUDAH FOUGHT HIM. Yes.

Witter was basically a bum when Judah fought him. Constantly going the distance, two draws...LOL...then fought a bunch of setups until he ran into a brick wall named Timothy Bradley.

Bradley fought Witter at Witter's peak. THAT is a decisive win.


Let's try this again. Name a fighter - SEASONED FIGHTER - that Zab Judah beat IN THEIR PRIME, DECISIVELY, that is a better fighter than Antonio DeMarco. You won't find any.

Judah either beat them when they were bums, beat them when they were journeymen, or got beat by them.

[Larry the boss]

Coin toss on zab and Gamboa Leaning towards gamboa because zab was weak between the ears. Broner was just good. Nowhere near as talented as those 2.

Gamboa was weak between the ears as well and accomplished far less then Judah..hell all 3 are weak between the ears

[Combat Talk Radio]

Listen, I'm not against a little clinch work, and rough house tactics on the inside, because I do agree that you have to know how to combat it, and even do it yourself, but what Hatton did wasn't normal boxing grappling, and clinching. He was on some UFC ish for that fight.

So was Grabomir Clinchko yet he continues to be heralded as one of the greatest Heavyweights.

We can't have it both ways. I'd rather just say, if your opponent doesn't do anything to stop it, keep doing it.

I remember Mills Lane once DQ'ng a guy for excessive clinching when he did a fraction of what Grabomir would do. I'm glad those days are gone.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Cory Spinks was essentially a journeyman WHEN JUDAH FOUGHT HIM. Yes.

Witter was basically a bum when Judah fought him. Constantly going the distance, two draws...LOL...then fought a bunch of setups until he ran into a brick wall named Timothy Bradley.

Bradley fought Witter at Witter's peak. THAT is a decisive win.


Let's try this again. Name a fighter - SEASONED FIGHTER - that Zab Judah beat IN THEIR PRIME, DECISIVELY, that is a better fighter than Antonio DeMarco. You won't find any.

Judah either beat them when they were bums, beat them when they were journeymen, or got beat by them.

Lmao..

Undisputed welter champ, that went on to win multiple 154 belts and nearly dethroned middleweight champ jermain taylor and you think he was a journeymen

Witter was a bum



Did you even watch boxing back then or you boxrec'n it

[powershots]

If Broner didn't **** ride floyd so much

[The Viper]

Cory Spinks was essentially a journeyman WHEN JUDAH FOUGHT HIM. Yes.

Witter was basically a bum when Judah fought him. Constantly going the distance, two draws...LOL...then fought a bunch of setups until he ran into a brick wall named Timothy Bradley.

Bradley fought Witter at Witter's peak. THAT is a decisive win.


Let's try this again. Name a fighter - SEASONED FIGHTER - that Zab Judah beat IN THEIR PRIME, DECISIVELY, that is a better fighter than Antonio DeMarco. You won't find any.

Judah either beat them when they were bums, beat them when they were journeymen, or got beat by them.

Witter was undefeated when he fought zab come on now.......

[W1LL]

I went with Zab Judah. There was a time when he had the potential to reign at the top. He still had a very good career but he could have been one of the best of his era. It's weird that Zab got stopped by Amir Khan later in his career. A prime Zab would have fncked Amir up bad.