Where do you actually put floyd in the ATG P4P List?

[TheBigLug]

Floyd is top 5 for me. All the criticism you can make about Floyd's resume, you can pick apart any ATG's resume in similar fashion if you have that agenda.

Not really a big Floyd fan but he's in the conversation as one of the very best. He's definitely the best of his era by some distance and that's really all you can be anyway.

[JJRod]

Among the best. Top 5.

[Johnny2x2x]

Floyd is top 5 for me. All the criticism you can make about Floyd's resume, you can pick apart any ATG's resume in similar fashion if you have that agenda.

Not really a big Floyd fan but he's in the conversation as one of the very best. He's definitely the best of his era by some distance and that's really all you can be anyway.

This is so accurate. Every resume can be picked apart if you hold it up to the same scrutiny that people hold Floyd's too.

Floyd dominated boxing for two decades, few in history can say that.

[amuroray]

Accident jezzz

[Larry the boss]

all i can say to threads like this is.............post your list..if you dont have one then dont say where he is ranked

[TMTForever99]

Top ten atg list

1. sugar ray robinson
2. floyd mayweather jr
3. henry armstrong
4. muhammad ali
5. Sugar Ray Leonard
6. Roy Jones Jr
7. Marvin Hagler
8. ezzard charles
9. Joe Louis
10. sam Langford

[Johnny2x2x]

Top ten atg list

1. sugar ray robinson
2. floyd mayweather jr
3. henry armstrong
4. muhammad ali
5. Sugar Ray Leonard
6. Roy Jones Jr
7. Marvin Hagler
8. ezzard charles
9. Joe Louis
10. sam Langford

Great list. Missing Duran for me.

[Johnny2x2x]

Top ten atg list

1. sugar ray robinson
1a. floyd mayweather jr
3. Ali
4. Roberto Duran
5. Sugar Ray Leonard
6. Henry Armstrong
7. Joe Louis
8. Harry Greb
9. Willie Pep
10. RJJ

[daggum]

Floyd is top 5 for me. All the criticism you can make about Floyd's resume, you can pick apart any ATG's resume in similar fashion if you have that agenda.

Not really a big Floyd fan but he's in the conversation as one of the very best. He's definitely the best of his era by some distance and that's really all you can be anyway.

almost all the all time greats have a least a couple great wins over prime greats....ali has liston, foreman etc...leonard has hearns, duran, etc...robinson has a bunch, floyd has....? i think its a pretty big oversight to put him in the same category as those guys.

how can yo be the best of your era when you never fouht the guys of your era until they were well past it? doesnt really seem fair....if spence were to beat floyd and pac right now does that make him the best of the era simply cause he won or is there more to it than that? you gotta fight when it matters. there is nitpicking and then there is waiting 5 years to fight guys that were recently ko'd. come on now.

[TMTForever99]

Great list. Missing Duran for me.

duran is top 20 for me..his lack of success outside of 135 doesn't justify a top ten ranking. he never successfully defended any title he won outside of 135. the greats win titles and defend them.

top 20:

11. jersey joe walcott
12. charlie burley
13. pernell whitaker
14. bernard hopkins
15. jack johnson
16. aaron pryor
17. thomas hearns
18. Lennox Lewis
19. Evander Holyfield
20. Roberto Duran