Comments Thread For: Heading into a Hectic Fall: BScene Pound-for-Pound Update

[My Low Place]

YAMANAKA has had one of the worst runs as champ..moreno gives him hell with after coming off about 2 losses? and this is rewarded?
WHY PPL?
HIS BEST win is a vic darch coming off a loss??
HOW IS THIS REWARDED...
u have former Foty winners that are still undefeated and they are not on the list? FOH!

[mdogger12]

ward doesn't deserve ****..

[1hourRun]

YAMANAKA has had one of the worst runs as champ..moreno gives him hell with after coming off about 2 losses? and this is rewarded?
WHY PPL?
HIS BEST win is a vic darch coming off a loss??
HOW IS THIS REWARDED...
u have former Foty winners that are still undefeated and they are not on the list? FOH!

To be fair one of those losses to Juan Carlos Payano was a technical decision as the fight was stopped due to a cut, then 'Chemito' had a close fight with Yamanaka in their first encounter resulting in a SD L. During this time (2014-2016) Anselmo was rated top five.

[My Low Place]

To be fair one of those losses to Juan Carlos Payano was a technical decision as the fight was stopped due to a cut, then 'Chemito' had a close fight with Yamanaka in their first encounter resulting in a SD L. During this time (2014-2016) Anselmo was rated top five.

I CANT ACCEPT THIS..not many divivisions have a top 5 guy coming off multiple losses..if the division is weak and the guy is not showing a skillset i never saw just about..he'sn ot p4p..his resume is weak and when he got a guy who is barely top 10 if we go by other divisions...HE STRUGGLED..he's an insult to the p4p list imo

[Combat Talk Radio]

I CANT ACCEPT THIS..not many divivisions have a top 5 guy coming off multiple losses..if the division is weak and the guy is not showing a skillset i never saw just about..he'sn ot p4p..his resume is weak and when he got a guy who is barely top 10 if we go by other divisions...HE STRUGGLED..he's an insult to the p4p list imo

Let it go man. All they care about is knockouts, not performance.

[Randall Cunning]

And the sheer lack of respeck to Jeff "The Hornet" Horn, ranked #8 P4P by BoxRec, #1 Welterweight in the World?

Thats a flaw in the Boxrec points system. A win over Manny will rack you up a ton of points.

[1hourRun]

I CANT ACCEPT THIS..not many divivisions have a top 5 guy coming off multiple losses..if the division is weak and the guy is not showing a skillset i never saw just about..he'sn ot p4p..his resume is weak and when he got a guy who is barely top 10 if we go by other divisions...HE STRUGGLED..he's an insult to the p4p list imo

You are a bit harsh on Chemito Moreno, find me a fighter in these divisions you refer to that have been on experts P4P list and ranked top five since 2008, its a shame you dismiss this man like hes inferior I suspect you do not keep up with the lighterweights :

Yes some of these divisions you speak of do not have contenders coming off one or two questionable losses ( as I already explained in Chemitos case ) but we are not ranking division here and to be objective when you have the body of work as Chemito you cant really compare the resume of these men you refer to in other weight classes or their accomplishments to Anselmos.

In addition you will find that a lot of these contenders in the top five are generally new to the sport...its easy to keep that 0 on your record at this point but you can also find seasoned vets in the top five with a couple losses in each division.

[1hourRun]

Thats a flaw in the Boxrec points system. A win over Manny will rack you up a ton of points.

Hes a troll or a boxrec warrior ( maybe both) , dismiss his opinions in these types of discussions.

[The Big Dunn]

Solid list. I wont argue with it.

[BrometheusBob.]

Mikey rated too high but not a terrible list