Comments Thread For: Heading into a Hectic Fall: BScene Pound-for-Pound Update

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Combat Talk Radio
    Banned
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • May 2015
    • 21727
    • 2,781
    • 6,368
    • 83,247

    #11
    Yeah I completely disagree with this list.

    Choco shouldn't be as high as he is after losing to Rungvisai. Period.

    And the sheer lack of respeck to Jeff "The Hornet" Horn, ranked #8 P4P by BoxRec, #1 Welterweight in the World?

    Comment

    • 1hourRun
      SQUAD-UP!
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Dec 2010
      • 20526
      • 2,789
      • 2,336
      • 140,312

      #12
      Originally posted by mlac
      looks like it was written by a hipster

      rigo is no.8? lmao for what? a win 4 years ago? seriously gtfoh

      'kovalev lost clean as a sheet' is that supposed to be ironic?
      Hey...umm wasn't Carl Frampton in the top ten P4P before Santa Cruz beat him in the rematch and was he not also the 2016 fighter of the year? so how is Guillermo Rigondeaux in the P4P getting dropped by bums and not beating anyone relevant in years in the P4P but Santa Cruz is not? so because Leo ducked him it does that bump Rigo up the rankings?

      Comment

      • 1hourRun
        SQUAD-UP!
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Dec 2010
        • 20526
        • 2,789
        • 2,336
        • 140,312

        #13
        Originally posted by revelated
        Yeah I completely disagree with this list.

        Choco shouldn't be as high as he is after losing to Rungvisai. Period.

        And the sheer lack of respeck to Jeff "The Hornet" Horn, ranked #8 P4P by BoxRec, #1 Welterweight in the World?
        robberies do not count in a objective panel.

        Comment

        • Combat Talk Radio
          Banned
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • May 2015
          • 21727
          • 2,781
          • 6,368
          • 83,247

          #14
          Originally posted by 1hourRun
          robberies do not count in a objective panel.
          "No matter how you...cut it, slice it or weigh it, he lost to Sor Rungvisai."

          There's simply no way a guy that lost should be above guys who haven't.

          The problem with this list is it's biased towards knockouts and stoppages rather than performances. Losing should drop your ranking much more than this list displays, period point blank.

          Garcia at #4 when the only name he's beaten is Broner who has never been a Top 10. LOL

          Comment

          • 1hourRun
            SQUAD-UP!
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Dec 2010
            • 20526
            • 2,789
            • 2,336
            • 140,312

            #15
            Originally posted by revelated
            "No matter how you...cut it, slice it or weigh it, he lost to Sor Rungvisai."

            There's simply no way a guy that lost should be above guys who haven't.

            The problem with this list is it's biased towards knockouts and stoppages rather than performances. Losing should drop your ranking much more than this list displays, period point blank.

            Garcia at #4 when the only name he's beaten is Broner who has never been a Top 10. LOL
            I'm not arguing Gonzalez should be above Ward, but you know you been trolling that Jeff the 'Ram' Horn beat the 'Pacman' so I guess responding to you was pointless and yeah about Mikey I already made that point.

            Comment

            • Mammoth
              Undisputed Champion
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Sep 2016
              • 35717
              • 3,848
              • 3,389
              • 378,304

              #16
              It is possible to score that Chocolatito fight as a loss. I thought he won but....

              Comment

              • Combat Talk Radio
                Banned
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • May 2015
                • 21727
                • 2,781
                • 6,368
                • 83,247

                #17
                Originally posted by 1hourRun
                I'm not arguing Gonzalez should be above Ward
                Re-read what I said and stop getting triggered over boys losing.

                I didn't say Choco shouldn't be on the list.

                I said he shouldn't be as high as they have him. No way. #8 AT BEST given who he lost to compared to the others on the list who haven't lost at all.

                By that logic Manny should be #3 after losing to a school teacher.

                Comment

                • My Low Place
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jun 2016
                  • 2101
                  • 67
                  • 0
                  • 10,944

                  #18
                  Originally posted by Shadoww702
                  Losing to Andre Ward does not mean you suk. He's still P4P top 10 in my list. If he loses again then I'll take him out of my list. I can't name 10 better then Kovalov right now.

                  And Andre Ward is #1 not no damn 9-1 Lomachenko who lost to a guy with 13 loses. He's in my top 10 but anyone has him #1 needs to slap themself.
                  bru he ducked the purse bid to fight adonis...beat up a 50 year old who he couldnt ko, and beat a washed up pascal...history will not recieve kov well if he quits today....2 losses in a row..and he quit and was turning his back.

                  Comment

                  • My Low Place
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jun 2016
                    • 2101
                    • 67
                    • 0
                    • 10,944

                    #19
                    oleksander gvodzyk has fought no top 10 guy in the lwh division under the age of 35 and he's a name for the future?
                    STOP IT BOXINGSCENE..the guy got dropped by karpency...adonis nearly killed karpency...and he's no where on the list at all? THIS BS MUST BE CALLED OUT.

                    Comment

                    • Real Talk85
                      Interim Champion
                      Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
                      • Apr 2014
                      • 686
                      • 43
                      • 0
                      • 7,277

                      #20
                      Originally posted by Conrad01
                      People slate Golovkin for his resume but its at least equal to Crawford's. Let's take their top 5 best

                      GGG: Jacobs, Lemeiux, Murray, Stevens, Brook

                      TC: Gamboa, Postol, Beltran, Burns, Diaz
                      The guys that Crawford beat are far more accomplished at their weight than the guys GGG fought.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP