Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

If everything was equal who wins these match ups

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #11
    Originally posted by THC View Post
    Winner is listed first:

    Rigodeaux vs Spence
    Crawford vs Ward
    Floyd vs Loma
    Hagler vs Duran
    Golovkin vs Thurman
    Canelo vs Porter
    Hearns vs Kovalev
    Leonard vs Pacquiao
    Pep vs Chocolatito
    Robinson vs Ali
    Rigo is far superior defensively and a master counter puncher; he would do Spence like he did Donaire.

    Arguably Crawford is just as versatile as Ward, can fight gritty, and he hits harder.

    Floyd can stymie anyone and that would reduce Loma's output. This fight depends on how well Loma can use his jab.

    We've seen Duran vs Hagler in which the former did well enough, but even if Duran was a natural MW, Hagler's toughness, versatility, and ring savvy would give him the edge.

    Along with his power, Golovkin has solid fundamentals which he can leverage to breakdown a technical, mobile fighter like Thurman.

    Porter is a good style match for Canelo.

    Hearns superior reach, outside game, and one-punch power is bad for Kovalev.

    Pacquiao is a good style match for Leonard.

    Pep's HoF skills, especially defense and movement, would frustrate Chocolatito to a decision win.

    Robinson is deservedly considered the greatest P4P fighter ever. This implies he beats anyone at any weight. I mean, can you imagine a prime WW Ray Robinson at 210 lbs!?

    Comment


    • #12
      Good stuff
      Last edited by DuckAdonis; 11-22-2017, 05:14 PM.

      Comment


      • #13
        I assume op just means if they were the same size

        Comment


        • #14
          Impossible to say because for a fighters attibutes aren't going to be the same in a completely different weight class.

          Comment


          • #15
            Originally posted by DuckAdonis View Post
            I assume op just means if they were the same size
            Yes, and fighters keep their speed, skills, and power.

            Comment


            • #16
              Originally posted by IronDanHamza View Post
              Impossible to say because for a fighters attibutes aren't going to be the same in a completely different weight class.
              Interesting. It's like if Roy was a welterweight. He would be a lot faster.

              Comment


              • #17
                Originally posted by THC View Post
                Rigo is far superior defensively and a master counter puncher; he would do Spence like he did Donaire.

                Arguably Crawford is just as versatile as Ward, can fight gritty, and he hits harder.

                Floyd can stymie anyone and that would reduce Loma's output. This fight depends on how well Loma can use his jab.

                We've seen Duran vs Hagler in which the former did well enough, but even if Duran was a natural MW, Hagler's toughness, versatility, and ring savvy would give him the edge.

                Along with his power, Golovkin has solid fundamentals which he can leverage to breakdown a technical, mobile fighter like Thurman.

                Porter is a good style match for Canelo.

                Hearns superior reach, outside game, and one-punch power is bad for Kovalev.

                Pacquiao is a good style match for Leonard.

                Pep's HoF skills, especially defense and movement, would frustrate Chocolatito to a decision win.

                Robinson is deservedly considered the greatest P4P fighter ever. This implies he beats anyone at any weight. I mean, can you imagine a prime WW Ray Robinson at 210 lbs!?
                Agree with most but I could see Spence breaking down Rigo and Ward out boxing Crawford due to being a better defensive fighter.

                Comment


                • #18
                  If Pacquiao and Rigo were 'naturally' as large as their hypothetical opponents they would be fat little nuggets.

                  Comment


                  • #19
                    haha true that

                    Comment


                    • #20
                      It's called pound for pound... who would win? That's all you have to say.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP