Not sure how I feel about your use of a 10-10 round in the 1st. I think if you look closely at that round, there is a clear winner by way of ringmanship and punch output? I had GGG edging that round, maybe only by a couple of jabs, and certainly close, but 10-10 should be rare and is a copout. 10-10 in this case just means that you don't know enough about boxing to be able to score
Here are the scoring directives from NYAC:
"In each round, such judges shall observe (1) clean hitting, (2) effective aggressiveness, (3) defense, and (4) ring generalship...
"(1) Round ends, no clear winner 10-10 (Rare); (2) Close round/Winning of the round by effective boxing – 10-9, etc. etc."
Here are the scoring directives from NYAC:
"In each round, such judges shall observe (1) clean hitting, (2) effective aggressiveness, (3) defense, and (4) ring generalship...
"(1) Round ends, no clear winner 10-10 (Rare); (2) Close round/Winning of the round by effective boxing – 10-9, etc. etc."
Comment