If Kovalev received the decision again Ward, would you have considered him #1 P4P

[daggum]

I consider Ward #1 since beating Kovalev, but if Kovalev won he should have been #1

that fight was close and could have gone either way. i consider ward #1 and kov #2 pfp right now. if kov had gotten the decision i would have him #1 and ward #2.

you guys realize p4p is just opinion right? you let corrupt boxing judges form your opinion? if you thought ward won for some reason cool then say hes the best. if you thought kovalev won then say likewise. if you think eric crumble is still the best like i do then say it.

[daggum]

Currently have them #1 and #2 P4P since I had the first fight a DRAW because I still have Round 10 EVEN after watching it like 5 Times but anyway talked about the first fight enough. Yes once again the winner of this is #1 P4P! Not sure how long they will remain because if Loma gets up to 135 and beat a Mikey Garcia that can elevate him #1 IMO

round 10 was a dominant kovalev round...how could it be a draw lmao. just fast forward and watch this vid and round 10.

[-PBP-]

hmm did you miss the fight?

Who needs to watch fights when we have the fair and objective BoxRec computer to make decisions for us?

[daggum]

Who needs to watch fights when we have the fair and objective BoxRec computer to make decisions for us?

boxrec ranking system and compubox are how trump gets all his info...

[j0zef]

No - it was close enough that no matter who got the nod doesn't deserve to be a clear #1. Still Roman IMO.

[bluebeam]

No kovalev wouldnt be p4p number 1 if he got the decision because after 12 rounds neither man separated himself from the other. That's why the rematch has to happen.

Ward vs Kovalev 2 winner is p4p number 1 if it's decisive

[NEETzsche]

It would have been harsh to unseat Roman without him losing first unless Ward or Kovalev had absolutely dominated the other

[JAB5239]

No kovalev wouldnt be p4p number 1 if he got the decision because after 12 rounds neither man separated himself from the other. That's why the rematch has to happen.

Ward vs Kovalev 2 winner is p4p number 1 if it's decisive

And what if it isn't decisive and another close decision come down? Does that mean neither are highly skilled and don't deserve the number one spot, or does it mean they are both excellent fighters who are just very evenly matched?

[PK3434]

No. It was very dumb for people to claim the winner should be pound 4 pound no matter what. How the fight plays out matters.

Both guys are top 5 in my opinion. Both guys could've fought better. We'll see what happens in the rematch.

[boliodogs]

I only go by my own scorecard. I had Kovalev the winner so I rank him above Ward PFP. I have GGG number 1, Kovalev number 2 and Loma number 3 with Ward number 4.