If brook beat spence, would he get much credit?

[JWHardin]

I would give Brook a HUGE amount of credit, and say he is the best welter out there or at least top 3. To date Brook has one credible win, and that was a very close fight. He only gets credit IF he fights Spence, and have my doubts.

The reason I don't think he will is his team pretty much has said Khan is 3X easier fight, and some consider Khan world class. (I don't) I really doubt if Brook has the confidence to take on Spence. Its pretty bad when everyone around you is trying to talk you out of the fight. Not the way to go into a tough fight.

Personally I think it would be a great fight, and not easy for either guy. Brook will have to decide to duck and take the heat from that, or fight and risk losing. I think he ducks.

[sicko]

Why wouldn't he? Anybody who "EXPOSES SPENCE JR FOR BEING A HYPE JOB" would get Credit! However I do think it is a reason why nobody is so EAGER to try and "EXPOSE HIM"

[Larry the boss]

why are you so against Spence?

[BoxingFan85]

no way would he deserve to be top 10 pfp, but yea hed get credit

errol spence and shawn porter alone dont make you pfp

Pretty much this ^^^

[BoxingFan85]

why are you so against Spence?

Because he is Brook's mandatory and Brook wants to fight Khan because as you know that's the fight he is confident of winning..

[boliodogs]

I would give him lots of credit. Right now I think Spence is a much better fighter and would KO him with no problem if they fought. If Brook won I would have to change my mind. A good win over Spence would put Brook in or near my top 10 pfp depending on how good he looked winning the fight. Right now I have a very high opinion of Spence. Not because of who he beat but because of the power, speed and skill he shows in all his fights.

[gmc_rfc_06]

Brook is the best WW in boxing, this would just stamp it.

[NaijaD]

How much credit would you give Brook for beating Khan who has already lost to Peterson, been KO'd by Garcia and brutally KO'd by Prescott and Canelo???

What can he do to Khan that hasn't been done before?

The way I see it is Spence has an 0 and is an undefeated American with a good amount of hype, resume wise I can't see how at this stage of their respective careers that Khan and his biscuit chin is worth more than Spence.

[DeLorean]

goes both ways. how much credit would Spence get beating Brook after he drops down to 147 with a fractured orbital bone? is he damaged goods? and Brook's only noteworthy win at 147 is Porter. is he really an "elite" welterweight with one decent win?

the criticism would come regardless of the outcome.

[HanzGruber]

Brook is the best WW in boxing, this would just stamp it.

what? lol pretty sure thurman garcia winner would be number 1 if not pac, brook has beat 1 guy in 10 years.. beating a guy who hasnt even won a title yet doesnt make you pfp