Will Canelo Be ATG If He Stops Golovkin??

[Rip Chudd]

Can you Tell me best micky Ward wins, thats right his Hofer ,Canelo wins and popularity gives him HoF if he retire now LMAO

Yeah that's the mentality we need to have, since they put less deserving people in let's just continue that trend. SMH

And I think you meant Gatti. I don't think Micky Ward is in the hall of fame

[Canelo and GGG]

Yeah that's the mentality we need to have, since they put less deserving people in let's just continue that trend. SMH

Fans dont put guys in HoF lol so i just state a fact

[Rip Chudd]

Fans dont put guys in HoF lol so i just state a fact

He isn't in the hall of fame. Gatti is

[Canelo and GGG]

He isn't in the hall of fame. Gatti is

Im pretty sure he is ,i will check it out later,but Gatti have no better wins Then Canelo.and Ginger is more popular.

[Larry the boss]

why not?

Marquez beat Pacquiao for size, he was always taller, think he had a longer reach too. Plus it was largely accepted that JMM had beaten him the last time Pac had faced him at welterweight. Plus it was widely acknowledged by the time that Pacquiao was no longer as fearsome.

it's a great win and currently the best win of this decade but if Canelo can beat a guy who is bigger, longer, hits harder and breaks bones by KO, especially a dominant KO, then I don't see how it's not a bigger or better win.

I know GGG isn't Pacquiao but dimensions are important. The 3 best wins of the decade so far have to be:

JMM over Pac
Fury over Wlad
May over Pac

At the very least, a KO of GGG sends Canelo over the bottom 2.

all these wins are over All time Greats GGG would be a damn good win for Canelo but GGG is not in those fighters class

[Scary]

Sure it would.

[Rip Chudd]

Im pretty sure he is ,i will check it out later,but Gatti have no better wins Then Canelo.and Ginger is more popular.

Ward is in the NJ hall of fame, not the IBHOF. While Canelo is popular, Gatti was more beloved

[soul_survivor]

all these wins are over All time Greats GGG would be a damn good win for Canelo but GGG is not in those fighters class

You're fixated on where GGG will be ranked in history but that's not how great wins are ranked.

[Mr.MojoRisin']

It would be a big win but not make him an ATG. To become an atg you have to be great in your own era. That means ducking nobody, fighting the best at there best when the opportunity is there, and be dominating over the guys you fought. There are certain exceptions, mainly to the dominating criterion.

[Scary]

It would be a big win but not make him an ATG. To become an atg you have to be great in your own era. That means ducking nobody, fighting the best at there best when the opportunity is there, and be dominating over the guys you fought. There are certain exceptions, mainly to the dominating criterion.

Ohh so nobody is ATG. I understand.