Golovkin's best win vs. Wilder's best win

[TheBoxingXpert]

Bermane Stiverne and Kell Brook are their best wins. There can be no doubt that Brook is a better fighter than Stiverne, but it can't be ignored that Brook was moving up 2 weight classes, which makes the wins comparable. So which win do you regard higher? Brook moving up 2 weight classes or Stivene?

EDIT: The subject here is NOT who got the better resume, so STFU about that. The subject is: Who of them got the one better defining win?

[boxinggod101]

For me they both have some question marks but Wilder as been fighting worst fighters than GGG.

Both have to step it up ASAP.

[BoxingFan85]

This is a no brainer, Golovkins fight with Murray, Lemeiux is greater than anyone on Wilders besides Stiverne.. GGG has fought sub par opponents and Wilders are below sub par..

[TheBoxingXpert]

For me they both have some question marks but Wilder as been fighting worst fighters than GGG.

Both have to step it up ASAP.

How are guys like Geale better than Malik Scott and Johann Duhaupas? Their wins are very much comparable.

But that's not the subject of this thread. The subject is who of them that got the one best defining win.

[mlac]

wilder has fought far worse competition, at least golovkin has been facing former belt holders top 10 guys etc

Wilder has fought LITERAL school teachers (eric molina)

It doesn't really get more embarrassing than that.

[TheBoxingXpert]

wilder has fought far worse competition, at least golovkin has been facing former belt holders top 10 guys etc

Wilder has fought LITERAL school teachers (eric molina)

It doesn't really get more embarrassing than that.

But that's not the subject of this thread. The subject is who of them that got the one best defining win.

[mlac]

But that's not the subject of this thread. The subject is who of them that got the one best defining win.

Brook.

Stirverne is garbage he just got battered and dropped by journeyman deric rossy.

[Redd Foxx]

Just to inject a dose of truth into this convo; The majority of people here picked Stiverne to win and Deontay was only a slight favorite in the betting odds. Almost no one picked Brook. Let's not pretend Brook is suddenly the better win. That's a lie of convenience.

[The Hammer]

Wilder has fought ONE opponent who was Ring/Transnational top ten.

Golovkin has fought at least 5 who were in the top ten when he fought them.

Geale
Murray
Macklin
Rubio
Lemieux

[boliodogs]

It seems to be impossible for you to go a single day without trashing GGG. So great is your insane hate of this excellent boxer. GGG has KO wins over Brook, Murray and fellow world champion Lemieux. Since Wilder was unable to KO Stiverne I would rate all three of these wins better than Wilder's only win over a top 10 world rated heavyweight. GGG also has KO wins over Geale and Rubio who were both rated in the top 10 in the world at the time he fought them. That makes KO wins over 2 world champions and at least 3 other top 10 contenders for GGG compared to Wilder's lone decision win over WBC champion Stiverne. Nobody else Wilder ever fought has been anywhere near top 10 in the world.