Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Brook. Khan. Who Is The Greater Fighter?

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Hmm Is the question asking who would win between them who has the better resume? I would say Khan's resume is slightly better, but Brook finishes Khan inside 4

    Comment


    • Khan resume is better ,i think he can beat Brook H2H too, Brook won with Porter and suddenly he is P4P ?no way i rate Thurman ,Garcia ,Bradley Even Vargas higher in WW right now.

      Comment


      • The TS isnt that clear on what he wants to know.
        I would say Brook is the better fighter although at one point i was thinking who the hell is brook, when Brook first started to challenge khan in press? I was thinking Brook is a bum, but then noticed his resume with a lot of wins. So i was think uumm interesting.

        But i woiuld say although khan has visually the better resume, Brook would beat khan, and would beat everyone on khans resume. So therefore Brook is the greater fighter. Resume can only take you so far. People say Nelo has better resume than GGG yet GGG destroys Nelo. So similar situation. Resume doesnt always make you a better fighter in peoples eyes. Pac had a better resume than Floyd all those years back, but floyd was still no1 pfp?
        Brook says he would beat everyone on GGGs resume as well, so at the very least you know you are dealing with one cheeky chappy.
        Last edited by hugh grant; 10-28-2016, 08:39 AM.

        Comment


        • Originally posted by KLockard23 View Post
          Brook. N*gga had four straight rounds won over GGG before the stoppage in the fifth. And as a remainder, the reason this fight has never happened is because Amir Khan keeps turning it down. He wants no part of Kell.
          I agree with everything here but your scorecard at the stoppage, lol.

          Comment


          • Brook has a lot to do but he is heading in the right direction Khan is clearly ahead of Brook and anyone who denies that is clearly just a Khan hater compare both achievements and opponents faced throughout Khan has fought better most of the time asides from the GGG fight and Porter fight which was very close could gone either way Brook doesn't hold better wins than Khan.

            I'm not really sold on how talented he is either we seen Golovkin absolutely toy with him imagine If he took that fight seriously it could have been a lot more damaging for Brook than it already was with his broken eye socket.

            Comment


            • Originally posted by KLockard23 View Post
              Brook. N*gga had four straight rounds won over GGG before the stoppage in the fifth. And as a remainder, the reason this fight has never happened is because Amir Khan keeps turning it down. He wants no part of Kell.
              Brook only won one of those rounds the whole fight was obvious home cooking but gladly very gladly Golovkin dominated so badly that the judges never got to rob GGG of his belts and his 0.

              However Khan was beating Canelo to the punch and outboxing him until he got caught with a big shot.

              Khan took the harder fight over Kell Brook yet he doesn't want to fight him he simply said Brook had to prove his worth its the exact same scenario with Joe Calzaghe and Carl Froch, why should Joe Calzaghe throw Carl Froch a bone when Froch hadn't done jack shiet explain that to me?

              Comment


              • Originally posted by Red Cyclone View Post
                Brook only won one of those rounds the whole fight was obvious home cooking but gladly very gladly Golovkin dominated so badly that the judges never got to rob GGG of his belts and his 0.

                However Khan was beating Canelo to the punch and outboxing him until he got caught with a big shot.

                Khan took the harder fight over Kell Brook yet he doesn't want to fight him he simply said Brook had to prove his worth its the exact same scenario with Joe Calzaghe and Carl Froch, why should Joe Calzaghe throw Carl Froch a bone when Froch hadn't done jack shiet explain that to me?
                Nelo knew he only needed one punch so Khan outpointingnelo should be taken with pinch of salt.

                Comment


                • Originally posted by hugh grant View Post
                  Nelo knew he only needed one punch so Khan outpointingnelo should be taken with pinch of salt.
                  The funny thing is that from round 4 Khan get out boxed and out smarted.Khan achived more and i give him good chance to beat Kell in H2H.If we are talking about GGG and Canelo i dont count this wins for them it was just money grab.

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by LacedUp View Post
                    Interim champion is not close to being world champion even if he was 1000 times interim champion he'd still only be interim chanpion. It's really that simple.

                    You can go off performances. For example, Brook took Matthew hatton to school. Same guy who gave Canelo a tough fight. Knocked out Senchenko in 4 rounds with no problems. Beat Shawn Porter away from home.

                    Khan has shown us his level by losing to a Colombian goat herder in the first round and getting knocked around like a rag doll by Willie Limond of all people. Knocked out by Garcia, lost to Peterson, knocked down by ***ing Diaz, getting mauled by A crude Maidana and knocked cold by Canelo.
                    Matthew Hatton gave Canelo a tough fight?

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by Red Cyclone View Post
                      Brook only won one of those rounds the whole fight was obvious home cooking but gladly very gladly Golovkin dominated so badly that the judges never got to rob GGG of his belts and his 0.

                      However Khan was beating Canelo to the punch and outboxing him until he got caught with a big shot.

                      Khan took the harder fight over Kell Brook yet he doesn't want to fight him he simply said Brook had to prove his worth its the exact same scenario with Joe Calzaghe and Carl Froch, why should Joe Calzaghe throw Carl Froch a bone when Froch hadn't done jack shiet explain that to me?
                      Carl Froch was the mandatory for Calzaghe's WBC belt.

                      He threw Mario Veit a bone in their epic rematch when he was mandatory.

                      He threw Ricky Thornberry a bone when he was mandatory.

                      He threw Mger Mkrtchyan a bone when he was mandatory.

                      Just not Carl Froch.

                      But for all these mandatories he took atleast we got great voluntaries such as Tucker Pudwill, Willy Mcintire and Branco Sobot. Hell, the epic USA vs UK clash on ITV with Peter Manfredo was a voluntary.

                      No bone for Carl Froch though.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP