Brook. Khan. Who Is The Greater Fighter?

[AliBombaye]

wouldn't take a lot. he's about one win away.

I bet you think his resume is better than Khan's right now don't you, sore little scrub you are, riding on the ball sacks of a 1 notable win fighter in 10 ****ING YEARS, what a joke just like his thinner than a hair follicle resume.

Let's hope the next time Brook makes ****esexual advances to a lone man in his apartment in the early hours of the morning the guy finishes the job and hopefully you can follow Kelly to his grave.

[Madison Boxing]

You know disgracefully the judges had Kell Brook ahead lol, Kell Brook was exposed last night GGG hit him whenever he wanted to he smashed his cheek/orbital bone and when Kell was brought into a war he crumbled bit by bit these are facts soon as Kell fought someone he didn't have a 20+ lbs advantage on he was getting schooled.

GGG landed more punches in every round you could only argue that Brook won the 2nd round but even at that... did he do enough to deserve it?

yeah I agree, im a brook fan but wasn't impressed at all, seem to be in the minority but he did a lot worse than I was expecting, thought he was going to clearly outbox GGG in early rounds, but I only gave him round 2 and he got beaten to a pulp in most of them. Wasn't just the power factor either, he couldn't move out the way of GGG when he started jabbing

[LoadedWraps]

None of those guys were better than Porter Stop talking bollocks.

I'm not saying Porter is a killer, but neither are the guys you mentioned. I mean, listen to yourself - you're mentioning Malignaggi, Judah and Kotelnik ffs

Maidana was a crude slugger when he fought Khan. Got schooled by an old ass Erik Morales just before Khan and was again schooled by Devon Alexander after. -> in case you didn't know, the guy Porter battered.

Porter has proven to be a tough fighter and a top welterweight.

Brook is my answer here in this thread, but you know I can't let you slide with calling Porter a better win than Maidana right?

At the time of the Porter fight, Maidana was a bigger name and is/was a better fighter.

At the time of the Maidana/Khan fight, sure, I'll give you that Porter was a better fighter then, pre-Garcia maidana is not the same as post-garcia maidana. But p4p prime for prime Maidana destroys Porter. If Maidana was at WW right now not a soul would beat him, the only Reason Bradley and Brook are in that 1-2 spot are because he retired. And you know I think really highly of Brook so don't think I am taking anything from him, just keeping it real here.

Also, it's hard to call Maidana a "best win" for Khan because if that fight goes one more round Khan loses that fight lol. He was surviving, and Khan tards like to act like he gave Marcos a beating. After he dropped him with a body shot he did nothing but try and survive. I do have a rematch thread and I will bump it if I need to to show that the majority of NSB had Maidana bodying him.

[alexguiness]

Brook is my answer here in this thread, but you know I can't let you slide with calling Porter a better win than Maidana right?

At the time of the Porter fight, Maidana was a bigger name and is/was a better fighter.

At the time of the Maidana/Khan fight, sure, I'll give you that Porter was a better fighter then, pre-Garcia maidana is not the same as post-garcia maidana. But p4p prime for prime Maidana destroys Porter. If Maidana was at WW right now not a soul would beat him, the only Reason Bradley and Brook are in that 1-2 spot are because he retired. And you know I think really highly of Brook so don't think I am taking anything from him, just keeping it real here.

I agree with most of what you have posted here but;

While I am a big Maidana fan, he would not be untouchable at 147 like you have stated.

Beating Broner and giving Floyd a tough first fight was his very best.

Pac, Brook, Spence and Thurman would likely beat 2014 Maidana.

Floyd picked him twice for a reason.

[LoadedWraps]

I agree with most of what you have posted here but;

While I am a big Maidana fan, he would not be untouchable at 147 like you have stated.

Beating Broner and giving Floyd a tough first fight was his very best.

Pac, Brook, Spence and Thurman would likely beat 2014 Maidana.

Floyd picked him twice for a reason.

I disagree with this.

To me the only fighters to trouble Maidana would be Bradley and Brook.

Pac would be 50/50. Maidana's defense is disgustingly underrated, strickingly similar to how GGG's is and Roman's is. Same subtle slips and rolls and parries.

I would bet all I have on Maidana stopping both Spence and Thurman. And sleep well at night.

I haven't seen Spence truly tested. I've seen Maidana come back from the brink and stand alone in victory. Thurman takes too many shots and enjoys exchanges. Maidana would maul him in the mid rounds and drop him.

[M Bison]

yeah I agree, im a brook fan but wasn't impressed at all, seem to be in the minority but he did a lot worse than I was expecting, thought he was going to clearly outbox GGG in early rounds, but I only gave him round 2 and he got beaten to a pulp in most of them. Wasn't just the power factor either, he couldn't move out the way of GGG when he started jabbing

Yeah that jab was brutal I think I recall the punch that likely screwed Brooks eye up.

This is the one that did it I believe, brutal shot power jab sets him up and boom in goes a thunderous right hand

[LoadedWraps]

Yeah that jab was brutal I think I recall the punch that likely screwed Brooks eye up.

This is the one that did it I believe, brutal shot power jab sets him up and boom in goes a thunderous right hand

What a combination it was, my goodness.

[AliBombaye]

What a combination it was, my goodness.

That right from Golovkin definately was not slow, I think he varies the speed of his punches a lot which is why a lot of people think he's so slow.

[LoadedWraps]

That right from Golovkin definately was not slow, I think he varies the speed of his punches a lot which is why a lot of people think he's so slow.

Yup, Roman also does the same.

[j0zef]

Brook >>>>>>> Khan.

Khan was knocked out for 5 minutes by 1 punch. the same type of punch that Canelo landed on Cotto multiple times and couldn't even put him down. Khan's chin is absolute glass. Khan would get KTFO by Golovkin in the 1st round and by Brook by the 4th.