Is kell brook better than canelo?

[PivotandRoll]

Dude margarito was 10x better then porter. From 2002 to 2009 besides a 3 month stretch margarito was world champ and elite welterweight with better wins then porter has ever had. Only welterweight to beat him during that stretch was p-will who would spank brook. You dumb phuk just keep name dropping long time Champs and hall of fames and elite fighters and just because you put porter name in that company don't make it so. All these guys deficate on porter and the rest of the bums brook has fought. Porter is no where near margarito and I'm not a fan of margarito.

He beat Cintron and Clottey. Both good wins. I'm very aware of his career.

[bigdunny1]

Calling Margs Elite doesn't make him so...

I stated facts , you stated opinions.

Margarito winning 3 titles and being a world champ for almost a decade makes him elite. He was the most feared fighter in boxing for about 5 years and on everybodies top lists. You calling porter elite or putting him in marg category just because brook beat him dont make it so. Porter don't have the resume of a elite fighter like Margarito does.

[PivotandRoll]

Margarito winning 3 titles and being a world champ for almost a decade makes him elite. You calling porter elite just because brook beat him ain't no fact. Porter don't have the resume of a elite fighter like Margarito does.

Broner is a four weight world champion.... I thought who you beat mattered.

No Porter is Elite because he went on to beat Broner and push Thurman to the edge even winning on some(wrong) cards.

Am I saying Porter is levels above Margs? **** no...But he's clearly the same level and Damn what a fight Margs and Porter would have been.

[icha]

Broner is a four weight world champion.... I thought who you beat mattered.

No Porter is Elite because he went on to beat Broner and push Thurman to the edge even winning on some(wrong) cards.

Am I saying Porter is levels above Margs? **** no...But he's clearly the same level and Damn what a fight Margs and Porter would have been.

porter elite??? really??? wow....

[PivotandRoll]

Margarito winning 3 titles and being a world champ for almost a decade makes him elite. You calling porter elite just because brook beat him ain't no fact. Porter don't have the resume of a elite fighter like Margarito does.

Look I'm really not trying to suck off Brook... I don't think Margs is as good as the Maidana who beat Broner.

Garcia's Maidana had the same awesome workrate as Margs with more power and better skills.

Dude I may be wrong...But to act like it's crazy to think Kell beats him is shortsighted IMO.

[PivotandRoll]

porter elite??? really??? wow....

As Elite as Margs....please learn the context of an argument before chiming in.

[DinoCop]

never watched both lol. (except when floid and larah)

[CaneloMaidana]

porter elite??? really??? wow....

He has to hype up Porter to hype Golovkin.

[bigdunny1]

Broner is a four weight world champion.... I thought who you beat mattered.

No Porter is Elite because he went on to beat Broner and push Thurman to the edge even winning on some(wrong) cards.

Am I saying Porter is levels above Margs? **** no...But he's clearly the same level and Damn what a fight Margs and Porter would have been.

Broner was a paper champ in almost all those weights with no long term reigns. Margarito was 3x champ all at welterweight and considered the man fought other greats and hall of famers. Don't be ****** acting like Broner ever had the status that margarito had and for almost a decade. Broner is a joke. And porter is not the same level one is a established elite fighter. The other is just another fighter who held a title once for a few months and that's it.

[PivotandRoll]

Broner was a paper champ is almost all those weights with no long term reigns. Margarito was 3x champ all at welterweight and considered the man fought other greats and hall of famers. Don't be ****** acting like Broner ever had the status that margarito had and for almost a decade. Broner is a joke. And he is not the same level one is a established elite fighter. The other is just another fighter who held a title once for a few months and that's it.

Broner has lost to Porter and Maidana....Margs has loses to complete nobodies...starting to think I'm just talking to a Margarito stan.