How do you rate Canelo?

[Larry the boss]

elite?
world class
solid fighter

a+
a
b+
b-
c
d
f???

[-PBP-]

A+ Floyd

A Pacquiao

A- Ward/Kovalev/Chocolatito/Rigondeaux

B+ GGG/Crawford/Loma (they will all be A level at some point but have yet to prove it against top opposition consistently)

B Canelo/Cotto/Bradley/Thurman/Garcia


I'd say about a B right now.

[New England]

i think he's going to get beaten by the very best of the best, but he's clearly a very good fighter.

i don't think he's quite as good as fernando vargas, for example, but his competition at 154 isn't as good as vargas' was, either.

[Madison Boxing]

B+ if that was a poll option. Think fighters who are elite beat him, and beat him pretty comfortably. Similar B level fighters like trout and lara gave him a hard time, and an A+ fighter in mayweather absolutely schooled him.

[aldo5408]

i think he's going to get beaten by the very best of the best, but he's clearly a very good fighter.

i don't think he's quite as good as fernando vargas, for example, but his competition at 154 isn't as good as vargas' was, either.

Are you serious? Do you also think Canelo is one dimensional like Withaker? Canelo already surpassed vargas ten times over . Canelo beat trout and Lara. Vargas got exposed by Winky and Shane FOH

[just the facts]

B+ if that was a poll option. Think fighters who are elite beat him, and beat him pretty comfortably. Similar B level fighters like trout and lara gave him a hard time, and an A+ fighter in mayweather absolutely schooled him.

just out of curiosity, where would you rate g string?

[Madison Boxing]

just out of curiosity, where would you rate g string?

Overall, A-. Hes not had a signature win or beaten a truly world class opponent but hes consistently blasted out good solid fighters. A couple of good wins after brook (hopefully jacobs, canelo and ramirez) and i put him as an A. THinking about it theres barely anyone in boxing at the moment who i would put as an A. Im not sure GGG is ever going to get the opposition in his career to end up proving hes an A+ fighter like mayweather etc, unless he goes in there and blasts someone like canelo out in a couple of rounds.

[SeekDaGreat]

B+, to A-.

Top 5 fighter in the entire game.

If he was in a video game he'd be ranked between 89-91 by me, out of 100.

[De Varona]

Rating Canelo

Canelo is not more than B

[Larry the boss]

Are you serious? Do you also think Canelo is one dimensional like Withaker? Canelo already surpassed vargas ten times over . Canelo beat trout and Lara. Vargas got exposed by Winky and Shane FOH

Whitaker was one dimensional????