Max Kellerman Manny Pacquiao Goat of our era (video)

[Redd Foxx]

You just summed up what Kellerman said..he said Floyd was obviously better head to head,but said Manny had a case due to all the divisions he climbed and said it was a matter of taste

Ok, thx for the summary. As obnoxious as Kellerman can be at times, I'll admit that I really appreciate him as a commentator who truly has a love for the sport, whether I agree with him or not.

As someone who has a deep appreciation for both May and Pac (though I like young May much more than young Pac and old Pac better than old May), threads like this are aggravating to no end because people refuse to relent any points to the other "side". I personally don't understand why more people don't like both guys, or why they have to "choose" but it is-what-it-is and I'm probably better off just not clicking on this shyt.

[Real King Kong]

Greatest of all time of our era? Typical spoon idiocy.

[Boxfan7819]

If you call that marathon event of a fight boxing maybe you have a point.

Not!

To be called a real Atg, one has to have a tight résumé with legendary battles that will be remembered through time, compelling fights that will be watched again for that classic match ups that gave exciting fights. Sadly, Floyd only has boring fights.


Did you even realize the four horsemen of this generation was Marquez, Morales, Barrer and Pacquiao. Floyd doesn't even have that kind of round robin.

While in the past was, Duran, SRL, MHagler, Herns.

That's what makes Pac's résumé stand out to have epic battles with other greats of this game. Sadly, pac's fight with Floyd wasn't epic since the guy ran for dear life lmao

Look at the fear on this man's eyes. Tells you everything really.

Lol damn wth

[Spoon23]

Are you really implying that Floyd took riskier fights than Pac? Use your same logic on Floyd's resume and you'll see that with few exceptions, Floyd took safe fights at safe times. He is a safety first fighter, his words, not mine.

I think he meant riskier dancing moves and tight hugs. Floyd's legacy, best hugger dancer in boxing.

[Spoon23]

I don't think you know what "GOAT" means.

Max meant of an era not as a whole.

It's just a hype title from the video uploader.

[Larry the boss]

Haven't I told you.. I don't recognize Floyd's win over manny.

If you can even call that a real fight. More like dancing with the stars more like it lmao

Epic battles define a real Atg. Pac has lots of those memorable fights that will be watched over and over. Floyd legacy is cherry picking at the right time, hence, he can never be above Pac since he fought Pac 6 years too late.

To bad what you recognize doesnt matter at all

[Spoon23]

To bad what you recognize doesnt matter at all

I was just elaborating what is already so clear

5 division lineal title

8 division champion

Nothing more to say really, but one last thing.

Don't shoot the messenger.

[Roy Keane]

Mayweather will go down in history as a better fighter. Manny is a ATG but he was beatable (only by other HOF/ATGs early loses don't count). They are very close but Mayweather has the slight edge. It's not a disgrace to be close to either fighter on a ATG list if you are that means you are

[Chuckguy]

Let's have spoon and Larry go at and let us vote who wins the debate??
Why the fawk not?

[Mike D]

I personally don't understand why more people don't like both guys, or why they have to "choose" but it is-what-it-is and I'm probably better off just not clicking on this shyt.

Yeah I've never got this either. It's like once you pick sides with one guy, you gotta automatically hate the other and trash him and discredit him at every opportunity. It's childish as f**k.