Max Kellerman Manny Pacquiao Goat of our era (video)

[Larry the boss]

Great way to post a misleading title...Max said Floyd was clearly beater head to head and both at top 10 atg's but just said Manny came up from a smaller division so he gets extra points for that...dude grow up and stop spinning ****..

[Larry the boss]

Ha. How desperate you are. It must have hurt your soul to hear him say that head to head, Mayweather is better.

Then he says it's close and P4P it's a matter of taste. Well, ok. It just so happens that most credible boxing buffs are going to have Mayweather ahead of Pacquaio as per their taste. You disagree, but you are biased.

So how about this. Go explore the internet and find an all time P4P ranking from any credible source that has Paquaio ranked ahead of Mayweather. I dare you?

I doubt you can even find one, but you can prove me wrong if you try. I promise I'll double the amount of lists you find with lists that have Mayweather ahead.

Deal?

Let's see if you step up or turn b*tch.

Yea he literally ignored all of that and as usual made up his own fantasy world

[BodiesInFlight]

I don't think you know what "GOAT" means.

[SilverMiles]

Manny has the better resume by far and took more risk in his career. The Floyd win over Manny would mean more if he got it in 2010 but he chose to duck the fight for 5+ years.

Manny is the better fighter ATG wise, what he has done will never be replicated. I can't say the same about Floyd.

[Larry the boss]

This is spot on facts

[Robbie Barrett]

1 persons opinion matters little, it's how they're viewed as a whole across the sport. The ESPN list that had Mayweather #1 took a panel of experts opinions and Mayweather came out on top.

[Robbie Barrett]

Mayweather was already viewed as greater than Pacquiao before he beat Pacquiao. The panel that decided this included Kellerman.



"Those polled were HBO broadcasters Jim Lampley and Max Kellerman; Showtime's Al Bernstein and Steve Farhood; freelance broadcaster and Nevada Boxing Hall of Fame founder Rich Marotta; promoter Lou DiBella; matchmaker Chris Middendorf; Associated Press national columnist Tim Dahlberg; retired AP boxing writer Ed Schuyler Jr.; boxing historian and writer Cliff Rold and myself."

http://sports.yahoo.com/news/where-floyd-mayweather--manny-pacquiao-rank-amongst-all-time-boxing-greats-062113734-boxing.html

[Larry the boss]

Mayweather was already viewed as greater than Pacquiao before he beat Pacquiao. The panel that decided this included Kellerman.



"Those polled were HBO broadcasters Jim Lampley and Max Kellerman; Showtime's Al Bernstein and Steve Farhood; freelance broadcaster and Nevada Boxing Hall of Fame founder Rich Marotta; promoter Lou DiBella; matchmaker Chris Middendorf; Associated Press national columnist Tim Dahlberg; retired AP boxing writer Ed Schuyler Jr.; boxing historian and writer Cliff Rold and myself."

http://sports.yahoo.com/news/where-f...34-boxing.html

Spoon23 just refuses to let this **** go,Manny is all he had and now he is gone...

[MurkaMan]

Manny has the better resume by far and took more risk in his career. The Floyd win over Manny would mean more if he got it in 2010 but he chose to duck the fight for 5+ years.

Manny is the better fighter ATG wise, what he has done will never be replicated. I can't say the same about Floyd.

Manny has a habit of fighting everyone at the right time! When they arent doing anything significant in the sport! I give him credit for being the smaller man, but theirs too many asterisk!

Margarita, Clottey, Mosley! None of them were making any noise when he faced them! Most of his fights above WW were meaningless victories imo! Bradley didnt go to ww and beat the best to earn a fight with Pac! Pac simply pulled him up to ww, had him fight a bum, then made a fight with him!

Even JMM was coming off a long layoff due to Golden Boy contract dispute, and had a bum fight where he knocked that guy out in one round!

When Floyd ducked Pac, he actually fought the absolute best around his weight class outside of Pac!

Big giant young guys who were always coming off very impressive victories! I think Berto was the only bum he faced!

And Floyd was always coming off long layoffs, or out of jail, and just dominating men that were really too big and young for him!

Its silly to lie about who's resume is stronger! Pac used the fact that Floyd was ducking him, to fight empty fights, and milk the sport by putting them on ppv! They didnt want Pac to lose as he waited for Floyd to fight him!

Floyd on the other hand was cleaning out any and every division around him! Taking risk with the money fight on the backburner! Dominated them all, then comes in beats Pac, and goes out undefeated!

[FrankieClutch]

Whether you agree or disagree, Max made a good point. Head to head, Floyd proved to be better, but someone isn't wrong for thinking Pacquiao is higher on a "Pound for pound" list.